Melino Katerina, Rankin Janet, Olson Joanne, Spiers Jude, Hilario Carla
Faculty of Nursing, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
School of Nursing, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, California, USA.
Nurs Inq. 2025 Apr;32(2):e70014. doi: 10.1111/nin.70014.
Recent discourse emphasizes the need to integrate social and structural determinants of health-such as poverty, violence, houselessness, and discrimination-into mental health care service design and delivery. This study investigates how psychiatric-mental health nurse practitioners (PMHNPs) navigate the conflicting demands of an efficiently organized clinic and the realities of patients experiencing chronic mental illness along with structural adversity. Using an institutional ethnographic approach, this research focused on the everyday work practices of nine PMHNPs in outpatient community mental health clinics in a major American city. The findings revealed disjunctures within two powerful discourses related to patient access to care that circulate in mental health settings: (1) "every door is an open door," and (2) "meeting people where they are." PMHNPs believe in the values promoted by the rhetoric while also being required to work outside institutional structures to meet real patient needs. By illustrating how the institutional coordination expected to improve health systems overlooks PMHNPs' expert knowledge, we highlight how addressing the "structural determinants of health" in clinical care for people with serious mental illnesses remains an ideological aspiration. We call for a reevaluation of mental health care practices and systemic transformation through the informed, ground-level interventions of PMHNPs.
近期的论述强调有必要将健康的社会和结构决定因素,如贫困、暴力、无家可归和歧视等,纳入精神卫生保健服务的设计和提供之中。本研究调查了精神科心理健康执业护士(PMHNPs)如何应对高效组织的诊所的相互冲突的要求,以及患有慢性精神疾病并面临结构逆境的患者的实际情况。采用制度民族志方法,本研究聚焦于美国一个主要城市的门诊社区精神卫生诊所中九名PMHNPs的日常工作实践。研究结果揭示了在精神卫生环境中流传的与患者获得护理相关的两种强大话语之间的脱节:(1)“每扇门都是敞开的门”,以及(2)“在人们所在之处与他们相遇”。PMHNPs认同这些言辞所宣扬的价值观,但同时也被要求在机构结构之外工作以满足患者的实际需求。通过说明预期改善卫生系统的机构协调如何忽视了PMHNPs的专业知识,我们强调了在严重精神疾病患者的临床护理中解决“健康的结构决定因素”仍然只是一种理想抱负。我们呼吁通过PMHNPs基于实际情况的明智干预,重新评估精神卫生保健实践并进行系统性变革。