Liu Caroline, Mavrommatis Maria M, Govindan Aparna, Cosetti Maura K
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, Las Vegas, Nevada, USA.
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, New York, USA.
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2025 Jun;172(6):1874-1881. doi: 10.1002/ohn.1246. Epub 2025 Apr 9.
Stigma is a human construct that guides community standards and opinions, often characterized by negative beliefs about a particular circumstance, quality, or person. This study reviews the literature for stigma related to hearing loss and hearing device use.
PubMed, Scopus, and Embase.
Databases were searched from inception to April 28, 2024. Two independent researchers screened articles and performed full-text reviews. Grounded theory was used to identify and analyze positive and negative themes across disparate qualitative data.
After screening 1096 abstracts, 45 full-texts and 4 conference abstracts were included including 17 studies in pediatric populations, 19 studies in adults of working age, and 14 studies in older adult populations. In pediatric populations, stigma is primarily tied to bullying and poor classmate perceptions, with school-based supports offering mixed results in minimizing perceived stigma. Among working and older age adults, common positive themes included improved quality of life and self-empowerment among hearing aid (HA) users. All working age studies refer to the role of HAs in creating a visible disability. The pervasive theme among older adults was being perceived as old or senile. Although studies were largely equal in gender representation, differential gender effects of stigma and HA decisions were identified.
Hearing loss stigma appears to be pervasive across age and gender with distinctions that have implications for intervention development. Future studies are needed to parse further nuances related to the stigma of hearing loss.
污名是一种人为构建的概念,它引导着社会标准和观念,通常表现为对特定情况、特质或个人的负面看法。本研究回顾了与听力损失及听力设备使用相关的污名的文献。
PubMed、Scopus和Embase。
对数据库从创建至2024年4月28日进行检索。两名独立研究人员筛选文章并进行全文综述。采用扎根理论来识别和分析不同定性数据中的正面和负面主题。
在筛选了1096篇摘要后,纳入了45篇全文和4篇会议摘要,其中包括17项针对儿童群体的研究、19项针对工作年龄成年人的研究以及14项针对老年人群体的研究。在儿童群体中,污名主要与欺凌行为和同学的不良看法相关,以学校为基础的支持措施在最小化感知到的污名方面效果不一。在工作年龄成年人和老年人中,常见的正面主题包括助听器(HA)使用者生活质量的改善和自我赋权。所有工作年龄的研究都提到了助听器在造成明显残疾方面的作用。老年人中普遍存在的主题是被认为年老或衰老。尽管研究在性别代表性方面大致相当,但确定了污名和助听器决策的不同性别影响。
听力损失污名似乎在年龄和性别上普遍存在,其差异对干预措施的制定具有影响。未来需要进一步研究来剖析与听力损失污名相关的细微差别。