Suliman Alsadig, Mohamed Amir, Saadeldein Mohamed
Department of General Surgery, Sudan Medical Specialization Board, Isbitalia Street, Downtown, Khartoum, Khartoum, Sudan.
Anatomy and Embryology, Department of Anatomy, Faculty of Medicine, University of Gezira, Isbitalia Street, Wad Madani, Gezira, Sudan.
Ann Med Surg (Lond). 2025 Mar 18;87(4):1930-1940. doi: 10.1097/MS9.0000000000003169. eCollection 2025 Apr.
Central venous catheterization (CVC) is a vital but technically demanding procedure that requires understanding of vascular anatomy to minimize complications and enhance patient safety. This study evaluates physicians' anatomical knowledge and confidence in CVC placement, focusing on the internal jugular vein (IJV), subclavian vein (SCV), and femoral vein (FV). It aims to identify critical knowledge gaps, assess their impact on procedural competency, and explore their association with complications. This research uniquely examines a low-resource setting where the reliance on anatomical landmarks is crucial due to limited ultrasound availability. The findings will inform targeted educational interventions to improve training, enhance procedural expertise, and ultimately optimize patient outcomes.
A single-center, hospital-based descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted among 164 medical practitioners using a structured questionnaire, validated through expert review and pilot testing. The questionnaire included image-based anatomical questions and a confidence scale to assess knowledge and self-reported proficiency in CVC insertion. Participants were randomized ensuring balanced subgroup representation. Statistical analyses, including chi-square tests, effect size calculations (Cohen's and Cramer's ), and confidence intervals, were performed to evaluate associations between demographic factors, anatomical knowledge, and confidence levels.
The study population had near-equal gender distribution (51.22% female, 48.78% male), with participants primarily being early-career physicians. The average knowledge accuracy was 86.03% for IJV, 82.9% for FV, and 86.9% for SCV. Significant associations were observed between anatomical knowledge and job title ( = 0.03), specialty ( = 0.02), and clinical experience ( = 0.02). Gender disparities were noted, with male participants scoring significantly higher for IJV ( = 0.04) and FV ( = 0.03), although no significant difference was found for SCV ( = 0.12). Confidence levels correlated with knowledge but did not necessarily reflect procedural competence, particularly in SCV insertion. The most frequently reported challenges included difficulty in vein identification (25.6%), and insufficient training (23.2%), reinforcing the need for structured educational interventions.
This study highlights the critical need for improved anatomical education and standardized training to enhance patient safety in catheterization. It uniquely contributes to the literature by identifying challenges specific to resource-limited settings, where clinicians rely heavily on anatomical knowledge due to the limited availability of imaging technology. The study's limitations include its single-center design, self-reported data, and cross-sectional nature, limiting generalizability and long-term trend analysis. Procedural competence was not directly assessed, emphasizing the need for objective evaluations. Future studies should focus on larger, multi-center designs with direct competency assessments to better identify training gaps. Additionally, exploring advanced educational methods, such as simulation-based training and virtual reality, could offer valuable insights into improving clinical skills in environments with constrained resources. Ultimately, this study highlights substantial knowledge gaps in CVC insertion, particularly among physicians with limited procedural exposure. Addressing these gaps through structured, evidence-based training programs is essential for patient safety.
中心静脉置管(CVC)是一项至关重要但技术要求较高的操作,需要了解血管解剖结构,以尽量减少并发症并提高患者安全性。本研究评估医生在CVC置管方面的解剖学知识和信心,重点关注颈内静脉(IJV)、锁骨下静脉(SCV)和股静脉(FV)。其目的是识别关键的知识差距,评估它们对操作能力的影响,并探讨它们与并发症的关联。本研究独特地考察了一个资源匮乏的环境,在该环境中,由于超声设备有限,对解剖标志的依赖至关重要。研究结果将为有针对性的教育干预提供依据,以改进培训、提高操作专业水平,并最终优化患者结局。
在一家单中心医院,对164名医学从业者进行了一项基于结构化问卷的描述性横断面研究,该问卷经专家评审和预试验验证。问卷包括基于图像的解剖学问题和一个信心量表,以评估CVC置管方面的知识和自我报告的熟练程度。参与者被随机分组,以确保亚组代表性均衡。进行了包括卡方检验、效应量计算(科恩d值和克莱默V值)以及置信区间在内的统计分析,以评估人口统计学因素、解剖学知识和信心水平之间的关联。
研究人群的性别分布接近相等(女性占51.22%,男性占48.78%),参与者主要是初入职场的医生。IJV的平均知识准确率为86.03%,FV为82.9%,SCV为86.9%。观察到解剖学知识与职称(P = 0.03)、专业(P = 0.02)和临床经验(P = 0.02)之间存在显著关联。注意到性别差异,男性参与者在IJV(P = 0.04)和FV(P = 0.03)方面的得分显著更高,尽管在SCV方面未发现显著差异(P = 0.12)。信心水平与知识相关,但不一定反映操作能力,特别是在SCV置管方面。最常报告的挑战包括静脉识别困难(25.6%)和培训不足(23.2%),这进一步凸显了进行结构化教育干预的必要性。
本研究强调了改进解剖学教育和标准化培训以提高置管患者安全性的迫切需求。它通过识别资源有限环境中特有的挑战,为文献做出了独特贡献,在这种环境中,由于成像技术有限,临床医生严重依赖解剖学知识。本研究的局限性包括其单中心设计、自我报告的数据以及横断面性质,限制了普遍性和长期趋势分析。未直接评估操作能力,强调了进行客观评估的必要性。未来的研究应侧重于更大规模的多中心设计,并进行直接的能力评估,以更好地识别培训差距。此外,探索先进的教育方法,如基于模拟的培训和虚拟现实,可能会为在资源受限环境中提高临床技能提供有价值的见解。最终,本研究凸显了CVC置管方面存在的重大知识差距,特别是在操作经验有限的医生中。通过结构化的、基于证据的培训计划来弥补这些差距对于患者安全至关重要。