Podkorytova Irina, Alick-Lindstrom Sasha, Ding Kan, Hays Ryan, Perven Ghazala
Department of Neurology, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, 5323 Harry Hines Blvd, Dallas, TX 75390-8508, USA.
J Clin Med. 2025 Mar 23;14(7):2184. doi: 10.3390/jcm14072184.
Temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) responds well to surgical treatment, although a considerable percentage of patients experience seizure recurrence after resection. Relapse from the contralateral mesial temporal lobe, extratemporal lobe epilepsy mimicking TLE, or temporal plus epilepsy might account for surgical failures. We included patients with a pre-implantation hypothesis suggesting TLE, who underwent stereo-EEG (SEEG) evaluation at our institution and had an individual SEEG exploration paradigm with at least twelve stereo-electrodes placed to sixteen brain regions allowing exploration of limbic and paralimbic networks. We analyzed the prevalence of TLE subtypes based on ictal onset localization with SEEG and response to resective surgery. Twenty-four subjects met the inclusion criteria. Seven patients had unilateral mesial temporal epilepsy (UMTE), five had bilateral mesial temporal epilepsy (BMTE), five had unilateral neocortical temporal epilepsy (UNTE), six had temporal-plus epilepsy (TPE), one had extratemporal epilepsy (ETE). The number of patients who underwent destructive surgeries and surgical outcomes are as follows: UMTE-all seven patients, Engel I; BMTE- three out of five, Engel I, III, and IV, respectively; UNTE-three out of five, Engel I; TLE mimic (ETE)-one, Engel I; TPE-all six patients, Engel I-three, Engel III-two, Engel IV-one. In our study, UMTE was the most frequent TLE subtype (29%), and all patients proceeded to resective surgery with good outcomes. TPE comprised a substantial component (25%) of this cohort with initially presumed TLE, who had a notable proportion of unfavorable outcomes. Larger studies are needed to create guidelines for rational counseling of patients with presumed TLE regarding surgical outcomes.
颞叶癫痫(TLE)对手术治疗反应良好,尽管相当一部分患者在切除术后会出现癫痫复发。对侧内侧颞叶复发、模仿TLE的颞叶外癫痫或颞叶加癫痫可能是手术失败的原因。我们纳入了植入前假设提示为TLE的患者,这些患者在我们机构接受了立体脑电图(SEEG)评估,并采用了个体SEEG探索模式,至少有12个立体电极放置在16个脑区,以探索边缘系统和边缘旁系统网络。我们根据SEEG的发作起始定位和对切除性手术的反应分析了TLE亚型的患病率。24名受试者符合纳入标准。7例患者患有单侧内侧颞叶癫痫(UMTE),5例患有双侧内侧颞叶癫痫(BMTE),5例患有单侧新皮质颞叶癫痫(UNTE),6例患有颞叶加癫痫(TPE),1例患有颞叶外癫痫(ETE)。接受破坏性手术的患者数量和手术结果如下:UMTE——所有7例患者,恩格尔一级;BMTE——5例中的3例,分别为恩格尔一级、三级和四级;UNTE——5例中的3例,恩格尔一级;TLE模仿型(ETE)——1例,恩格尔一级;TPE——所有6例患者,恩格尔一级3例、恩格尔三级2例、恩格尔四级1例。在我们的研究中,UMTE是最常见的TLE亚型(29%),所有患者均接受了切除性手术,效果良好。TPE在最初推测为TLE的这一队列中占相当大的比例(25%),其不良结果的比例显著。需要开展更大规模的研究,以制定针对推测为TLE患者手术结果进行合理咨询的指南。