Yan Hong-Yu, Wang Yu-Fen, Young Yi-Ho
Departments of Otolaryngology, National Taiwan University Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan.
Department of Medical Imaging, National Taiwan University , Taipei, Taiwan.
Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2025 Apr 12. doi: 10.1007/s00405-025-09379-9.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the long-term outcome of Meniere's disease (MD) patients who had previously undergone sac and shunt operation using Hydrops MRI for assessment.
A total of 17 unilateral MD patients who had previously undergone sac and shunt operation underwent an inner ear test battery, followed by Hydrops MRI. The 34 ears were classified into two groups. Group A consisted of 17 operated ears, which were further subdivided into Group A1 (with endolymphatic hydrops, EH), and Group A2 (without EH). In contrast, Group B comprised 17 non-operated (opposite) ears including Group B1 (with EH) and Group B2 (without EH).
More than 70% MD patients continued to experience the Meniere's triad of symptoms, even long-term (20 years) after surgery. A significantly decreasing sequence in the abnormality rates of the inner ear test battery was noted in Group A1 + B1, whereas no such declining trend was noted in Group A2 or B2. The prevalence of EH on operated ears demonstrated EH at the cochlea (65%), saccule (53%), and utricle (53%). Additionally, EH was also identified on non-operated ears, with a prevalence of 24% at the cochlea, and 12% at the saccule and utricle.
Using Hydrops MRI, this study found a 65% prevalence of cochlear EH on operated ears over a long-term period after surgery. This, coupled with a 70% prevalence of episodic vertigo, suggests that sac and shunt operation may not effectively alleviate EH.
本研究旨在评估既往接受过囊袋及分流手术的梅尼埃病(MD)患者的长期预后,并使用积水MRI进行评估。
共有17例既往接受过囊袋及分流手术的单侧MD患者接受了一套内耳检查,随后进行积水MRI检查。34只耳朵被分为两组。A组由17只手术耳组成,进一步细分为A1组(伴有内淋巴积水,EH)和A2组(无EH)。相比之下,B组包括17只未手术的(对侧)耳朵,分为B1组(伴有EH)和B2组(无EH)。
超过70%的MD患者即使在术后长期(20年)仍持续出现梅尼埃三联征症状。A1 + B1组内耳检查异常率呈显著下降趋势,而A2组或B2组未观察到这种下降趋势。手术耳中EH的发生率显示,耳蜗为65%,球囊为53%,椭圆囊为53%。此外,未手术耳也发现有EH,耳蜗的发生率为24%,球囊和椭圆囊为12%。
本研究使用积水MRI发现,术后长期手术耳的耳蜗EH发生率为65%。这与发作性眩晕70%的发生率相结合,表明囊袋及分流手术可能无法有效缓解EH。