From the Department of Radiology (A.F.J.), Massachusetts Eye and Ear, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts
Department of Otolaryngology (K.-Y.L.), Shin Kong Wu Ho-Su Memorial Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2024 Sep 9;45(9):1363-1369. doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A8339.
Menière disease (MD) manifests in 2 major endotypes: one with a hypoplastic, underdeveloped endolymphatic sac (MD-hp) and the other with a normally developed sac that degenerates over time (MD-dg). Determining the specific endotype in patients is important for predicting disease progression, tailoring patient counseling, and optimizing treatment strategies. Endotype diagnosis involves measuring an angular trajectory of the vestibular aqueduct (ATVA), with an ATVA ≥140° indicative of MD-hp and an ATVA ≤120° of MD-dg. However, assessing the ATVA can be challenging. This study aimed to explore the link between ATVA and the thickness of the retrolabyrinthine bone as an alternative diagnostic measure that could provide differentiation between MD endotypes using CT and MR imaging.
Retrospective review of CT temporal bone imaging from 32 adult patients with definite MD (60 ears) and 33 age-matched controls without MD or other inner ear symptoms (61 ears) was performed. The ATVA and retrolabyrinthine bone thickness were measured using uniform methodology on standardized axial CT images. Comparative analyses were performed to determine the correlation between ATVA and retrolabyrinthine bone thickness. Additionally, from a separate cohort of 11 patients (22 ears), CT and MR examinations of the temporal bone were retrospectively reviewed for retrolabyrinthine bone thickness measurements, to verify the correlation across the 2 modalities.
The average retrolabyrinthine bone thickness was statistically significantly different between MD endotypes, being a mean of 0.8 (SD, 0.3) mm in patients with MD-hp (ATVA ≥140°) and 2.0 (SD, 0.9) mm in patients with MD-dg (ATVA ≤120°), with a consistent pattern of thin retrolabyrinthine bone in MD-hp and variable thickness in MD-dg. Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis within the MD cohort revealed that a retrolabyrinthine bone thickness ≥1.2 mm effectively rules out MD-hp. Excellent interrater reliability was noted for the retrolabyrinthine measurement, and there was near-perfect correlation between CT and MR measurements.
Retrolabyrinthine bone thickness proved to be a useful and straightforward alternative marker for distinguishing MD endotypes, being particularly useful for excluding MD-hp. Including information on retrolabyrinthine bone thickness should be considered a routine part of reporting in the context of MD imaging.
梅尼埃病(Ménière disease,MD)表现为 2 种主要的内型:一种是内淋巴管囊发育不全(hypoplastic,underdeveloped endolymphatic sac,MD-hp),另一种是随着时间的推移囊逐渐退化(degenerates over time,MD-dg)。确定患者的具体内型对于预测疾病进展、定制患者咨询和优化治疗策略非常重要。内型诊断包括测量前庭水管(vestibular aqueduct,ATVA)的角度轨迹,ATVA≥140°提示 MD-hp,ATVA≤120°提示 MD-dg。然而,评估 ATVA 可能具有挑战性。本研究旨在探讨 ATVA 与迷路后骨厚度之间的联系,作为一种替代诊断方法,使用 CT 和 MR 成像来区分 MD 内型。
对 32 例成人 MD 患者(60 耳)和 33 例年龄匹配的无 MD 或其他内耳症状的对照组(61 耳)的 CT 颞骨成像进行回顾性分析。使用统一的方法在标准化的轴向 CT 图像上测量 ATVA 和迷路后骨厚度。进行对比分析以确定 ATVA 与迷路后骨厚度之间的相关性。此外,对 11 例(22 耳)患者的 CT 和 MR 颞骨检查进行回顾性分析,以验证两种模式之间的相关性。
MD 内型之间的迷路后骨厚度存在统计学显著差异,MD-hp(ATVA≥140°)患者的平均迷路后骨厚度为 0.8±0.3mm,MD-dg(ATVA≤120°)患者为 2.0±0.9mm,MD-hp 表现为迷路后骨变薄,MD-dg 表现为迷路后骨厚度可变。MD 组的受试者工作特征曲线分析显示,迷路后骨厚度≥1.2mm 可有效排除 MD-hp。迷路后测量的观察者间信度良好,CT 和 MR 测量之间存在近乎完美的相关性。
迷路后骨厚度是一种有用且简单的区分 MD 内型的替代标志物,对于排除 MD-hp 尤其有用。在 MD 成像报告中应考虑包含迷路后骨厚度信息作为常规内容。