Sparks Teresa N, Cruz Martinez Rogelio, Van Mieghem Tim
Division of Maternal-Fetal Medicine and Reproductive Genetics, Department of Obstetrics, Gynecology, & Reproductive Sciences, University of California, San Francisco, California, USA.
Prenatal Diagnosis and Fetal Surgery Center, Fetal Medicine Mexico Institute, Guadalajara, Mexico.
Prenat Diagn. 2025 Sep;45(10):1351-1358. doi: 10.1002/pd.6784. Epub 2025 Apr 13.
This manuscript summarises the debate held at the 2024 annual meeting of The International Society for Prenatal Diagnosis (ISPD). Experts discussed whether all fetuses undergoing fetal therapy should undergo exome sequencing. Arguments in favor included that, with increasing experience and better clinical availability, exome sequencing can yield valuable diagnostic and prognostic information beyond what is available from karyotyping and microarray. This additional information is often helpful in counseling parents and provides a better understanding of fetal conditions, allowing for personalised medicine and supporting advancements in disease-focused fetal therapies. On the contrary, however, significant concerns regarding availability and health equity were raised. Moreover, potential delays in care incurred by exome sequencing may negatively affect outcomes of fetal intervention. Finally, as the information gathered from genetic testing may or may not affect pregnancy management decisions beyond termination of pregnancy, many families may choose not to undertake testing. The arguments of both debaters document current controversies in exome sequencing and genetic testing in general. This was also reflected in a divided audience vote at the end of the debate.
本手稿总结了在国际产前诊断学会(ISPD)2024年年会上举行的辩论。专家们讨论了是否所有接受胎儿治疗的胎儿都应进行外显子组测序。支持的观点包括,随着经验的增加和临床可用性的提高,外显子组测序能够产生超出核型分析和微阵列所提供的有价值的诊断和预后信息。这些额外信息通常有助于为父母提供咨询,并更好地了解胎儿状况,从而实现个性化医疗,并支持以疾病为重点的胎儿治疗的进展。然而,相反的是,人们对外显子组测序的可用性和健康公平性提出了重大担忧。此外,外显子组测序导致的潜在治疗延迟可能会对胎儿干预的结果产生负面影响。最后,由于从基因检测中收集的信息可能会也可能不会影响除终止妊娠之外的妊娠管理决策,许多家庭可能会选择不进行检测。两位辩论者的观点记录了外显子组测序和一般基因检测当前存在的争议。这也反映在辩论结束时观众意见分歧的投票中。