We previously reported optimisation of the methodology to mitigate blooms and associated loss of microbial diversity when using the micro-Matrix bioreactor platform as an model of the human distal colon. Here, we provide further critical insights that we have gained in this regard through follow-up experiments. We tested four separate faecal fermentation media compositions for the purposes of such distal colon model experiments and found that the media composition described by MacFarlane is the most suitable for mitigating such microbial blooms, and concurrently, maintaining microbial diversity. We also tested if pooled or individual donor faecal samples were more suitable and found that pooled samples performed better in terms of maintaining gut microbiota diversity in such batch culture model experiments using the micro-Matrix system. Finally, we determined that prolonged experiments, i.e. for durations of up to 96 h, may be warranted with a view to affording particularly fastidious gut microbes an opportunity to grow and compete with their less fastidious counterparts. Essentially, we provide critical insights into:•Optimal faecal fermentation media to minimise blooms and preserve diversity in colon model experiments•Optimal faecal inoculum source and duration of experiments.