Siddiqui Sarah B, Everling Kathleen M, Patel Premal, Serag Hani
Division of General Internal Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston, Galveston, TX, USA.
Office of Educational Development, John Sealy School of Medicine, University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston, Galveston, TX, USA.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 Apr 15;25(1):542. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07137-3.
With the call to integrate health systems science (HSS) in medical education curriculum comes the need for more practical guidance from implementation experiences. In June 2020, the University of Texas Medical Branch John Sealy School of Medicine implemented a required course entitled "Health Systems Science and Community Service (HSS)" for fourth-year medical students. This quality improvement study describes the course and the lessons learned in the first four iterations.
The course was formatted as a 10-month-long, asynchronous course that ran concurrently with post-clerkship rotations. Throughout the four iterations, we used close- and open-ended questions to systematically collect students' feedback twice annually. Descriptive analysis of quantitative data was performed, and general themes were drawn from qualitative items from the evaluations. In addition, the National Board of Medical Examiner (NBME) HSS Subject Examination was administered in the course during the third and fourth iterations; student performance was analyzed. The course contents were iteratively revised each year to incorporate more HSS and community service components.
The course cohorts 1 through 4 from each iteration had 234, 221, 220, and 217 students, respectively. The response rates for the end-of-year course evaluations were 91% for cohorts 1, 2, and 3, and 94% for cohort 4. Most students reported that the amount of material they were required to cover was reasonable across all four iterations. While most respondents from cohorts 1, 2, and 4 found the number of community service hours reasonable, the majority of respondents in cohort 3 indicated it was excessive. The common themes from students' responses across cohorts included that some of the course content should have been taught in earlier years of their medical training, that community service activities are valuable but should have been optional, and that students appreciated the flexibility of the course. Student performance on the NBME exam was comparable to national performance. We summarized the iterative changes for each cohort based on feedback.
We described the implementation of a post-clerkship course on health systems science integrating with community service and service-learning. A major lesson learned was the need to take an iterative approach in building components like service-learning and addressing challenges, including student buy-in.
随着将卫生系统科学(HSS)纳入医学教育课程的呼声响起,需要从实施经验中获得更多实用指导。2020年6月,德克萨斯大学医学分部约翰·西利医学院为四年级医学生开设了一门必修课,名为“卫生系统科学与社区服务(HSS)”。这项质量改进研究描述了该课程以及在前四轮教学中吸取的经验教训。
该课程为期10个月,采用异步教学形式,与临床实习后的轮转课程同时进行。在四轮教学过程中,我们每年两次使用封闭式和开放式问题系统收集学生的反馈。对定量数据进行描述性分析,并从评估中的定性项目中提取一般主题。此外,在第三轮和第四轮教学期间,该课程还进行了美国国家医学考试委员会(NBME)的卫生系统科学科目考试;对学生成绩进行了分析。每年对课程内容进行迭代修订,以纳入更多的卫生系统科学和社区服务内容。
四轮教学中各批次的学生人数分别为:第一批234人、第二批221人、第三批220人、第四批217人。第一、二、三批学生年终课程评估的回复率为91%,第四批为94%。大多数学生报告说,在四轮教学中,他们需要学习的材料量是合理的。虽然第一批、第二批和第四批的大多数受访者认为社区服务小时数合理,但第三批的大多数受访者表示过多。各批次学生回答的共同主题包括:部分课程内容应在医学培训的早期阶段教授;社区服务活动很有价值,但应是选修的;学生们赞赏该课程的灵活性。学生在NBME考试中的表现与全国水平相当。我们根据反馈总结了每一批次的迭代变化。
我们描述了一门临床实习后开设的卫生系统科学课程的实施情况,该课程将社区服务与服务学习相结合。吸取的一个主要经验教训是,在构建服务学习等组成部分以及应对包括学生接受度在内的挑战时,需要采取迭代方法。