Zhang Cheng, Wu Jianying, Ma Shumei, Zheng Xiaozhi
Department of Ultrasound, Weihai Municipal Hospital, Weihai, China.
Department of Cardiovascular Surgery, Qinghai University Affiliated Hospital, Xining, China.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2025 Apr 1;15(4):2766-2773. doi: 10.21037/qims-24-832. Epub 2025 Mar 25.
Intraoperative blood loss (IBL) is a common complication of carotid body paraganglioma (CBP) resection, and contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) can quantitatively assess the perfusion of CBP. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the performance of CEUS in predicting the IBL in patients undergoing resection for CBP.
This study included 10 consecutive patients who underwent CBP surgery and preoperative evaluation of CBP perfusion via CEUS between November 2020 and December 2021. The correlation between CEUS enhancement pattern and quantitative perfusion parameters and IBL were determined using stepwise multiple regression analysis.
The median age of the 10 patients was 57 [interquartile range (IQR), 51-66] years old, and 8 of them were female. The IBL ranged from 10 to 800 mL, with a median of 100 (IQR, 20-400) mL. The sizes of CBPs in the ≥50 mL IBL group, in the ≥100 mL group, and in the ≥400 mL group were significantly larger than those in the <50 mL group, <100 mL group, and <400 mL group (P<0.05), respectively. CBPs of Shamblin type I accounted for a higher proportion in the <50 mL group and in the <100 mL group as compared to the other groups (P<0.05). Grade 1 CEUS enhancement pattern was more common in the <100 mL group, and grade 3 CEUS enhancement pattern was more common in the ≥100 mL group (P<0.05). Stepwise multiple regression analysis indicated that the maximum diameter of CBP (D) and the enhancement pattern of CBP were independent predictors of IBL (P<0.05). The regression equation of Model 1 was y = 14.735 × -211.314 (R=0.669; R-adjusted =0.629; P=0.004), where x and y are the D (mm) and IBL (mL), respectively. The regression equation of Model 2 was y = 200 × -215 (R=0.434; R-adjusted =0.364; P=0.038), where x and y are the enhancement pattern of the CBP and IBL (mL), respectively. Model 1 was more powerful than was Model 2 in predicting IBL ≥50 mL, [area under the curve (AUC) 1.000 (0.692-1.000) . 0.881 (0.532-0.995), P<0.05; sensitivity 100% . 71.43%, P<0.05; specificity 100% . 100%, P>0.05; Youden index 1.000 . 0.714, P<0.05] and IBL ≥400 mL [AUC 0.952 (0.622-1.000) . 0.857 (0.505-0.991), P<0.05; sensitivity 100% . 100%, P>0.05; specificity 85.71% . 71.43%, P<0.05; Youden index 0.857 . 0.714, P<0.05]. Meanwhile, Model 2 and Model 1 demonstrated comparable strength in predicting IBL ≥100 mL [AUC 0.979 (0.660-1.000) . 0.958 (0.630-1.000), P>0.05; sensitivity 83.33% . 83.33%, P>0.05; specificity 100% . 100%, P>0.05; Youden index 0.833 . 0.833, P>0.05].
The D and CEUS enhancement pattern can be used as imaging biomarkers for predicting IBL in CBP resection: the former is better for predicting IBL ≥50 mL and ≥400 mL, while the latter is better for predicting IBL ≥100 mL.
术中失血(IBL)是颈动脉体副神经节瘤(CBP)切除术中的常见并发症,而超声造影(CEUS)可定量评估CBP的灌注情况。本研究旨在评估CEUS在预测CBP切除术患者IBL方面的性能。
本研究纳入了2020年11月至2021年12月期间连续10例行CBP手术并通过CEUS对CBP灌注进行术前评估的患者。采用逐步多元回归分析确定CEUS增强模式与定量灌注参数及IBL之间的相关性。
10例患者的中位年龄为57岁[四分位间距(IQR),51 - 66岁],其中8例为女性。IBL范围为10至800 mL,中位值为100(IQR,20 - 400)mL。IBL≥50 mL组、≥100 mL组和≥400 mL组的CBP大小分别显著大于<50 mL组、<100 mL组和<400 mL组(P<0.05)。与其他组相比,Shamblin I型CBP在<50 mL组和<100 mL组中占比更高(P<0.05)。1级CEUS增强模式在<100 mL组中更常见,3级CEUS增强模式在≥100 mL组中更常见(P<0.05)。逐步多元回归分析表明,CBP的最大直径(D)和CBP的增强模式是IBL的独立预测因素(P<0.05)。模型1的回归方程为y = 14.735× - 211.314(R = 0.669;调整后R = 0.629;P = 0.004),其中x和y分别为D(mm)和IBL(mL)。模型2的回归方程为y = 200× - 215(R = 0.434;调整后R = 0.364;P = 0.038),其中x和y分别为CBP的增强模式和IBL(mL)。在预测IBL≥50 mL时,模型1比模型2更有效[曲线下面积(AUC)1.000(0.692 - 1.00). 0.881(0.532 - 0.995),P<0.05;敏感性100%. 71.43%,P<0.05;特异性100%. 100%,P>0.05;约登指数1.000. 0.714,P<0.05]以及预测IBL≥400 mL时[AUC 0.952(0.622 - 1.00). 0.857(0.505 - 0.991),P<0.05;敏感性100%. 100%,P>0.05;特异性85.71%. 71.43%,P<0.05;约登指数0.857. 0.714,P<0.05]。同时,在预测IBL≥100 mL时,模型2和模型1表现出相当的效能[AUC 0.979(0.660 - 1.00). 0.958(0.630 - 1.00),P>0.05;敏感性83.33%. 83.33%,P>0.05;特异性100%. 100%,P>0.05;约登指数0.833. 0.833,P>0.05]。
D和CEUS增强模式可作为预测CBP切除术IBL的影像学生物标志物:前者在预测IBL≥50 mL和≥400 mL方面表现更佳,而后者在预测IBL≥100 mL方面表现更佳。