Nagano China, Morisada Naoya, Inoki Yuta, Tanaka Yu, Ichikawa Yuta, Ueda Chika, Kitakado Hideaki, Aoto Yuya, Sakakibara Nana, Horinouchi Tomoko, Yamamura Tomohiko, Ishimori Shingo, Nozu Kandai
Department of Pediatrics, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine, 7-5-2 Kusunoki-Cho, Chuo-Ku, Kobe, Hyogo, 650-0017, Japan.
Department of Clinical Genetics, Hyogo Prefectural Kobe Children's Hospital, 1-6-7 Minatojima-Minamimachi, Chuo-Ku, Kobe, Hyogo, 650-0047, Japan.
Clin Exp Nephrol. 2025 Apr 17. doi: 10.1007/s10157-025-02675-y.
Autosomal-dominant tubulointerstitial kidney disease caused by MUC1 (ADTKD-MUC1) is a rare disorder characterized by progressive kidney dysfunction. Pathogenic variants in MUC1 are difficult to detect owing to the variable number tandem repeat region. To address this issue, VNtyper-Kestrel, a bioinformatics pipeline for short-read sequencing data, was recently developed. In this study, the performance of VNtyper-Kestrel for detecting MUC1 variants in clinical settings was evaluated.
We used VNtyper-Kestrel to retrospectively analyze short-read sequencing data for 209 individuals with suspected ADTKD who were previously evaluated through long-read sequencing. Data from a panel including ~ 180 genes and an ADTKD-specific panel were used. In addition, the pipeline was applied to 976 patients with suspected hereditary kidney diseases other than ADTKD and positive cases were validated using long-read sequencing. Accuracy was assessed by comparisons with the results of long-read sequencing.
Using VNtyper-Kestrel, we identified MUC1 variants in 16 of 19 confirmed cases of ADTKD-MUC1. Three initially negative cases were reanalyzed using the ADTKD-specific panel, yielding positive detection results with high confidence. We obtained two low-confidence positive results from 190 cases of suspected ADTKD and 10 low-confidence positive results among 976 non-ADTKD cases; however, all were classified as false positives upon long-read sequencing validation.
VNtyper-Kestrel demonstrated high sensitivity in identifying MUC1 variants when sequencing coverage was adequate, supporting its potential as a rapid and cost-effective screening tool. However, confirmatory long-read sequencing is needed in uncertain cases. Optimizing coverage and refining patient selection criteria could improve the clinical utility of this approach.
由MUC1引起的常染色体显性遗传性肾小管间质性肾病(ADTKD-MUC1)是一种罕见疾病,其特征为进行性肾功能障碍。由于可变数目串联重复序列区域,MUC1中的致病变异难以检测。为解决这一问题,最近开发了一种用于短读长测序数据的生物信息学流程VNtyper-Kestrel。在本研究中,评估了VNtyper-Kestrel在临床环境中检测MUC1变异的性能。
我们使用VNtyper-Kestrel对209例疑似ADTKD个体的短读长测序数据进行回顾性分析,这些个体先前已通过长读长测序进行评估。使用了一个包含约180个基因的基因panel和一个ADTKD特异性panel的数据。此外,该流程应用于976例疑似非ADTKD遗传性肾病患者,并使用长读长测序对阳性病例进行验证。通过与长读长测序结果进行比较来评估准确性。
使用VNtyper-Kestrel,我们在19例确诊的ADTKD-MUC1病例中的16例中鉴定出MUC1变异。对3例最初为阴性的病例使用ADTKD特异性panel进行重新分析,得到了高可信度的阳性检测结果。我们从190例疑似ADTKD病例中获得了2个低可信度阳性结果,在976例非ADTKD病例中获得了10个低可信度阳性结果;然而,经长读长测序验证后,所有结果均被分类为假阳性。
当测序覆盖度足够时,VNtyper-Kestrel在鉴定MUC1变异方面表现出高灵敏度,支持其作为一种快速且经济高效的筛查工具的潜力。然而,在不确定的病例中需要进行确证性长读长测序。优化覆盖度和完善患者选择标准可提高该方法的临床实用性。