Eker Ola Al, Imam Asma
Public Health, Al-Quds University, Jerusalem, Occupied Palestinian Territory.
Health Management, Faculty of Public Health, Al-Quds University, Jerusalem, Occupied Palestinian Territory.
Int J Equity Health. 2025 Apr 17;24(1):106. doi: 10.1186/s12939-025-02444-z.
Inequalities in the provision, distribution and utilization of healthcare services are the most commonly used variables to measure health system equity. Health inequalities in the Palestinian health system are evidenced due to geopolitical and socioeconomic challenges. This study evaluates the equity of healthcare resource distribution and utilization in the West Bank, focusing on primary healthcare centers and hospital services managed by the Palestinian Ministry of Health over a six-year period (2017-2022).
The data was extracted from the Annual Health Reports for the investigated six years, covering the eleven governorates of the West Bank. The distribution of primary healthcare centers, hospital beds, and health workforce was assessed using standardized measures per population and geographic area, service utilization trends were analyzed across governorates. The Gini coefficient was calculated to evaluate equity in resource allocation.
Disparities in resources allocation and services expansion and utilization are noticed among the different governorates. Hospital services expanded at a higher rate (18.5% increase in beds, and 5.8% increase in standardized beds ratio to population) compared to PHC centers (6.8% increase in centers, and - 4.63% for the standardized ratio of PHC centers to population). The rates varied widely among different governorates in both areas. Human resources growth rates lagged behind infrastructure expansion. Despite these inequities, the Gini coefficient values suggested relatively balanced resource allocation at the population level ranging between 0.078 and 0.164, though higher values for Gini coefficients and inequalities are found for resources distribution by geographic area.
The findings emphasize the urgent need for a strategic equity-oriented approach that integrates community needs, geographic accessibility and workforce development. Comprehensive plans for strengthening healthcare services at different levels; focusing on PHC services and aligning workforce growth with infrastructure expansion are essential for achieving universal health coverage in Palestine.
医疗服务的提供、分配和利用方面的不平等是衡量卫生系统公平性最常用的变量。由于地缘政治和社会经济挑战,巴勒斯坦卫生系统存在健康不平等现象。本研究评估了约旦河西岸医疗资源分配和利用的公平性,重点关注巴勒斯坦卫生部管理的初级医疗中心和医院服务,为期六年(2017 - 2022年)。
数据取自所调查六年的年度健康报告,涵盖约旦河西岸的11个省份。使用按人口和地理区域的标准化指标评估初级医疗中心、医院病床和卫生人力的分布情况,分析各省份的服务利用趋势。计算基尼系数以评估资源分配的公平性。
不同省份在资源分配、服务扩展和利用方面存在差异。与初级医疗中心相比,医院服务扩张速度更快(病床增加18.5%,标准化病床与人口比例增加5.8%),而初级医疗中心方面(中心增加6.8%,初级医疗中心与人口的标准化比例下降4.63%)。这两个领域在不同省份的增速差异很大。人力资源增长率落后于基础设施扩张。尽管存在这些不平等现象,但基尼系数值表明在人口层面资源分配相对平衡,介于0.078至0.164之间,不过按地理区域划分的资源分配的基尼系数值和不平等程度更高。
研究结果强调迫切需要采取以公平为导向的战略方法,整合社区需求、地理可达性和劳动力发展。加强不同层面医疗服务的综合计划;重点关注初级医疗服务并使劳动力增长与基础设施扩张保持一致,对于在巴勒斯坦实现全民健康覆盖至关重要。