Valli Aashobanaa Duraisaminathan, Alberti Hugh, Brown Megan
School of Medicine, Newcastle University, Newcastle, UK.
School of Medicine, Newcastle University, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, UK.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 Apr 21;25(1):582. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07181-z.
Asian ethnic women face discrimination within UK medical schools. Their experiences, shaped by intersecting identities, demand focused attention and understanding. This study aims to explore their experiences, especially on understanding how the intersecting identities shape their educational journeys.
An interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA) approach was used to explore lived experiences and perceptions of five fourth-year medical students from one institution. Transcripts from semi-structured interviews were analysed following IPA procedures, with an emphasis on understanding the intersectionality of gender and ethnicity in shaping experiences.
Analysis of the transcripts produced four overarching themes with six subthemes. The four themes were: discriminatory action, impact, reaction to the action and expectations and solutions. 'Discriminatory action' highlights the direct and indirect discrimination that the students faced. Students' personal sense of identity shaped the 'impact' theme whilst perseverance, tolerance and acceptance of discrimination defined the 'reaction' theme. The 'expectations and solutions' theme reflects how students anticipate change and propose solutions to mitigate these issues. Participants strongly urged institutions to take more proactive steps in addressing these concerns.
Discrimination significantly impacts the wellbeing and education of Asian women medical students. These challenges have implications for career progression and contribute to broader inequities in medicine. We recommend medical schools consider including a curriculum to address these concerns as a priority in the early years of the medical degree.
亚裔女性在英国医学院校面临歧视。她们的经历受到多种身份交叉的影响,需要得到重点关注和理解。本研究旨在探索她们的经历,特别是了解多种身份交叉如何塑造她们的教育历程。
采用解释性现象学分析(IPA)方法,探索来自一所院校的五名四年级医学生的生活经历和看法。按照IPA程序对半结构化访谈的文字记录进行分析,重点是理解性别和种族交叉在塑造经历方面的作用。
对文字记录的分析产生了四个总体主题和六个子主题。这四个主题分别是:歧视行为、影响、对行为的反应以及期望与解决方案。“歧视行为”突出了学生们所面临的直接和间接歧视。学生的个人身份认同感塑造了“影响”主题,而对歧视的坚持、容忍和接受则定义了“反应”主题。“期望与解决方案”主题反映了学生们如何期待改变并提出缓解这些问题的解决方案。参与者强烈敦促院校采取更积极主动的措施来解决这些问题。
歧视对亚裔女医学生的幸福和教育产生重大影响。这些挑战对职业发展有影响,并导致医学领域更广泛的不平等。我们建议医学院校考虑将解决这些问题的课程作为医学学位早期阶段的优先事项。