Lam Phoebe Pui Ying, Cabalen Maria Belen, Peng Simin, Wong Hai Ming Gloria, Botelho Michael George
Paediatric Dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, the University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam, Hong Kong SAR, Hong Kong.
Becaria CONICET, Facultad de Ciencias de la Salud, Universidad Católica deCórdoba, Córdoba, Argentina.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2025 Apr 22. doi: 10.1111/eje.13093.
Vicarious learning has demonstrated potential in dental education, particularly in enhancing cognitive engagement, analytical thinking, and self-efficacies among students. This study examined the impact of implementing a series of vicarious learning dialogue videos (VLDVs) to improve the critical thinking, operative skills, and confidence of newly engaged dental undergraduate students in paediatric dentistry.
VLDVs were accessible to students through the university learning platform for self-directed access in a paediatric dentistry clinical course. Seventy-six dental students who had begun treating paediatric patients were recruited for the study. A comprehensive research approach was utilised, incorporating video viewing analysis, focus group interviews with thematic analyses, and questionnaire surveys to evaluate the VLDVs in terms of usage, general impressions, functionality, and application to learning.
The evaluation of the VLDVs demonstrated favourable perceptions among students who were new to paediatric dentistry. Four main themes were identified, including learning resources, observational learning, empathy, and affordance phenomena. VLDVs were highly regarded for their contribution to the clinical transitional process, particularly in simulating real clinical procedures and providing informative content. Students utilised the VLDVs for revision, skill refinement, and preparation for assessments, often consuming them prior to performing procedures in the clinic. Vicarious learning through VLDVs was observed to stimulate critical thinking, prevent errors, and enhance self-confidence.
VLDVs effectively facilitate critical thinking and improve students' operative skills, preparedness, and confidence. This video genre shows promise in aiding the transition from simulation laboratory to real-life practice in treating paediatric patients.
替代性学习已在牙科教育中展现出潜力,特别是在增强学生的认知参与度、分析思维和自我效能方面。本研究考察了实施一系列替代性学习对话视频(VLDV)对提高初涉儿科牙科的牙科本科新生的批判性思维、操作技能和自信心的影响。
学生可通过大学学习平台访问VLDV,以便在儿科牙科临床课程中进行自主学习。本研究招募了76名已开始治疗儿科患者的牙科学生。采用了综合研究方法,包括视频观看分析、进行主题分析的焦点小组访谈以及问卷调查,以从使用情况、总体印象、功能以及对学习的应用等方面评估VLDV。
对VLDV的评估显示,儿科牙科新手学生对其看法良好。确定了四个主要主题,包括学习资源、观察性学习、同理心和可供性现象。VLDV因其对临床过渡过程的贡献而受到高度评价,特别是在模拟实际临床操作和提供信息性内容方面。学生将VLDV用于复习、技能提升和评估准备,常在临床操作前观看。观察发现,通过VLDV进行的替代性学习可激发批判性思维、预防错误并增强自信心。
VLDV有效地促进了批判性思维,提高了学生的操作技能、准备程度和自信心。这种视频类型在帮助从模拟实验室过渡到治疗儿科患者的实际操作方面显示出前景。