Charest Nathaniel, Sinclair Gabriel, Eytcheson Stephanie A, Chang Daniel T, Martin Todd M, Lowe Charles N, Paul Friedman Katie, Williams Antony J
Office of Research and Development, Center for Computational Toxicology and Exposure, United States Environmental Protection Agency, 109 TW Alexander Dr., Research Triangle Park, North Carolina 27711, United States.
J Chem Inf Model. 2025 May 12;65(9):4426-4441. doi: 10.1021/acs.jcim.5c00713. Epub 2025 Apr 24.
New approach methodologies (NAMs) are an increasing priority in the field of toxicology to fill data gaps and reduce time and resources in chemical safety assessment. We describe an NAMs workflow that integrates an high-throughput bioassay with an computational model. In defining this workflow, we propose, as a crucial step of development, the identification of explicit "purpose contexts": definitions of the scope and intent of an solution, which provide natural targets for the mechanistic interpretation, validation, and output design of the model. By inspecting data from an assay measuring the displacement of fluorescent probe 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonic acid (ANSA) from the serum transport protein transthyretin (TTR) as a proxy for potential disruption of thyroxine (T4) binding, in collaboration with the experimenters, we developed three relevant purpose contexts for this modeling effort: (1) examination and confirmation of the assay principle via orthogonal information, (2) immediate integration with the experimental cycle to reduce costs and enhance hit rates, and (3) ultimate replacement of the use of single-concentration screening as a prioritization strategy for bioactivity testing of bulk chemical libraries. From these purpose contexts, we derived the foundations of a robust and transparent quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) model that is constructively fit for purpose, characterized by first-principles mechanistic analysis, strict data quality evaluation, contextually rigorous performance testing and, finally, delivery of a quantitative recommendation schedule to simultaneously improve hit rates and model learning potential.
新方法学(NAMs)在毒理学领域愈发重要,旨在填补数据空白并减少化学安全性评估中的时间和资源消耗。我们描述了一种将高通量生物测定与计算模型相结合的NAMs工作流程。在定义此工作流程时,我们提议,作为开发的关键步骤,明确识别“目的背景”:即解决方案范围和意图的定义,为模型的机理解释、验证及输出设计提供自然目标。通过与实验人员合作,检查一项测量荧光探针8-苯胺基-1-萘磺酸(ANSA)从血清转运蛋白甲状腺素运载蛋白(TTR)上的位移以替代甲状腺素(T4)结合潜在干扰的测定数据,我们为该建模工作开发了三个相关目的背景:(1)通过正交信息检查和确认测定原理;(2)立即与实验周期整合以降低成本并提高命中率;(3)最终取代单浓度筛选作为大量化学文库生物活性测试优先级策略的使用。基于这些目的背景,我们得出了一个稳健且透明的定量构效关系(QSAR)模型的基础,该模型建设性地适用于目的,其特点是基于第一性原理的机理解析、严格的数据质量评估、严格的上下文性能测试,最后提供定量推荐时间表以同时提高命中率和模型学习潜力。