Muller C, Marshall C L, Krasner M, Cunningham N, Wallerstein E, Thomstad B
Med Care. 1977 Mar;15(3):251-9. doi: 10.1097/00005650-197703000-00006.
This paper reports on the cost effectiveness of a pediatric primary care system utilizing nurse practitioners (NPs) linked to a physician consultant through bidirectional interactive cable television. In addition, it discusses ways in which multiple uses enhance the economic feasibility of a telemedicine consultation link in a given geographic area. The overall consultation rate during periods of remote physician coverage was 21 per cent, compared with 24 per cent during on-site coverage. The telephone became a partial substitute for the TV for some uses but could not replace it in diagnostic decisions. As telemedicine is obviously underutilized in a one-satellite system, we compare a five-satellite network with other ways of delivering service. The resulting estimated cost of $18.50 an hour, or 2/3 of the cost of a physician providing direct care, includes a TV component of $5.30 an hour of use in a 1,750-hour year. The critical factor is that the NP can be a physician substitute if there is TV backup. The TV appears to prevent unnecessary referrals compared to a physician on site. Whether TV increases the length of the consult compared to the phone for conditions of equal severity is not entirely clear. If TV is compared to transporting a patient to a central place, the implicit value of transport time and disutility required to justify using TV is $7.55 per consult in a five-clinic network. Geographic and other barriers to physician availability enhance the potential for application fo telemedicine.
本文报告了一种儿科初级保健系统的成本效益,该系统利用执业护士(NP)通过双向交互式有线电视与医生顾问建立联系。此外,还讨论了多种用途如何提高特定地理区域远程医疗咨询链接的经济可行性。远程医生覆盖期间的总体咨询率为21%,而现场覆盖期间为24%。在某些用途上,电话部分替代了电视,但在诊断决策中无法取代电视。由于远程医疗在单卫星系统中明显未得到充分利用,我们将五卫星网络与其他服务提供方式进行了比较。由此得出的每小时估计成本为18.50美元,即医生直接护理成本的2/3,其中包括在一年1750小时的使用中每小时5.30美元的电视成本部分。关键因素是,如果有电视备用支持,执业护士可以替代医生。与现场医生相比,电视似乎可以防止不必要的转诊。对于同等严重程度的病情,电视咨询时间是否比电话咨询时间长尚不完全清楚。如果将电视与将患者转运到中心地点进行比较,在五诊所网络中,每次咨询使用电视所需的隐含转运时间价值和负效用为7.55美元。医生可及性的地理和其他障碍增加了远程医疗应用的潜力。