Jani Ronak H, Raju Sudesh, Kim Miri, Gardner Paul, Zenonos Georgios A, Snyderman Carl, Wang Eric W, Patel Chirag, Germanwala Anand V
Department of Neurological Surgery, Loyola University Medical Center, Maywood, Illinois, United States.
Department of Neurological Surgery, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States.
J Neurol Surg B Skull Base. 2024 May 3;86(3):295-302. doi: 10.1055/a-2301-3867. eCollection 2025 Jun.
While the endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA) has become a well-established surgery for resection of craniopharyngiomas (CP), the utility of this procedure following subtotal resection from open transcranial approach (TCA) surgery has yet to be explored. Here we present a multi-institutional case series of patients who underwent EEA for treatment of recurrent CP originally treated by TCA, demonstrating the viability of this approach as salvage surgery. Retrospective cohort. Loyola University Medical Center and University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. Patients who underwent EEA for recurrent CP following an initial TCA between 2003 and 2018. Gross total resection (GTR) rate, surgical complications, visual outcomes, and endocrine outcomes Patients who underwent EEA for recurrent CP following a prior TCA had a GTR rate of 77%. EEA reoperation was not associated with worsening of visual outcomes as compared with the primary TCA (0% visual worsening after EEA reoperation vs. 40% after primary TCA, = 0.055). While primary TCA resulted in worsening endocrinopathies in 100% of patients (including seven patients with permanent diabetes insipidus), subsequent EEA for re-resection of CP resulted in stable (30.8%) or improved (69.2%) endocrine function in all patients ( < 0.001). EEA achieves reasonable GTR rates and is an effective, safe surgical option for recurrent CP postinitial TCA. This approach demonstrated stable or improved visual and endocrinologic outcomes in all patients within our two-institution series. Thus, EEA should be considered as an efficacious form of retreatment in cases of progressive and recurrent CP.
虽然鼻内镜下经鼻入路(EEA)已成为一种成熟的颅咽管瘤(CP)切除术式,但这种手术在经颅开放手术(TCA)次全切除术后的应用尚未得到探索。在此,我们展示了一组多机构病例系列,这些患者接受了EEA治疗最初经TCA治疗的复发性CP,证明了这种方法作为挽救性手术的可行性。
回顾性队列研究。
洛约拉大学医学中心和匹兹堡大学医学中心。
2003年至2018年间因复发性CP接受EEA治疗且最初接受过TCA的患者。
大体全切除(GTR)率、手术并发症、视力结果和内分泌结果
先前接受过TCA后因复发性CP接受EEA的患者GTR率为77%。与初次TCA相比,EEA再次手术与视力结果恶化无关(EEA再次手术后视力恶化率为0%,而初次TCA后为40%,P = 0.055)。虽然初次TCA导致100% 的患者内分泌病变恶化(包括7例永久性尿崩症患者),但随后对CP进行再次切除的EEA使所有患者的内分泌功能稳定(30.8%)或改善(69.2%)(P < 0.001)。
EEA能达到合理的GTR率,是初次TCA后复发性CP有效的、安全的手术选择。在我们的两机构系列研究中,这种方法在所有患者中都显示出稳定或改善的视力和内分泌结果。因此,对于进行性和复发性CP病例,EEA应被视为一种有效的再治疗方式。