Maeda Hiromichi, Endo Hideki, Seishima Ryo, Hibi Taizo, Takeuchi Masashi, Takemura Yusuke, Yamamoto Hiroyuki, Taketomi Akinobu, Kakeji Yoshihiro, Seto Yasuyuki, Ueno Hideki, Mori Masaki, Shirabe Ken, Kitagawa Yuko
Department of Surgery Kochi Medical School Kochi Japan.
Department of Healthcare Quality Assessment, Graduate School of Medicine The University of Tokyo Tokyo Japan.
Ann Gastroenterol Surg. 2024 Dec 23;9(3):608-618. doi: 10.1002/ags3.12900. eCollection 2025 May.
To evaluate the impact of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic on short-term outcomes of low anterior resection (LAR) across hospitals classified by surgical volume.
Data of patients who underwent elective LAR for rectal cancer between 2018 and 2022 were obtained from the National Clinical Database of Japan. Hospitals were categorized into high-, medium-, and low-volume groups. Each group was constituted to represent approximately one-third of all surgeries performed between 2018 and 2019. The standardized morbidity/mortality ratios (SMRs) of Clavien-Dindo grade ≥3 (CD ≥ 3) complications were the primary endpoint. The secondary endpoints included anastomotic leakage, pneumonia, and surgical mortality.
This study analyzed 91 800 cases of elective LAR, with 10.5% experiencing CD ≥ 3 complications, 8.8% anastomotic leakage, 0.9% pneumonia, and 0.5% surgical mortality. Despite COVID-19, SMRs of CD ≥ 3 complications decreased from 2018 to 2022 across all groups. However, increases in the rates and SMRs of CD ≥ 3 complications were observed in low-volume hospitals around mid-2020, followed by a decline. Anastomotic leakage showed similar trends. The rates and SMRs of pneumonia and surgical mortality remained unchanged. Notably, anastomotic leakage rates were 7.6%, 8.9%, and 10.0% in high-, medium-, and low-volume hospitals, respectively, indicating superior outcomes in high-volume hospitals.
Early COVID-19 waves may have disproportionately affected low-volume hospitals. However, the decline in SMRs of CD ≥ 3 complications from 2018 to 2022 across all three groups suggests the robustness and resilience of surgical services for rectal cancer in Japan. The potential disparity in short-term outcomes among hospitals is a new concern.
评估冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行对不同手术量分类医院低位前切除术(LAR)短期结局的影响。
从日本国家临床数据库获取2018年至2022年期间因直肠癌接受择期LAR的患者数据。医院被分为高手术量、中等手术量和低手术量组。每组约占2018年至2019年期间所有手术的三分之一。Clavien-Dindo分级≥3(CD≥3)并发症的标准化发病率/死亡率比(SMRs)为主要终点。次要终点包括吻合口漏、肺炎和手术死亡率。
本研究分析了91800例择期LAR病例,10.5%发生CD≥3并发症,8.8%发生吻合口漏,0.9%发生肺炎,0.5%发生手术死亡率。尽管有COVID-19疫情,2018年至2022年期间所有组的CD≥3并发症的SMRs均有所下降。然而,在2020年年中左右,低手术量医院的CD≥3并发症发生率和SMRs有所上升,随后下降。吻合口漏呈现类似趋势。肺炎和手术死亡率的发生率和SMRs保持不变。值得注意的是,高、中、低手术量医院的吻合口漏发生率分别为7.6%、8.9%和10.0%,表明高手术量医院的结局更好。
COVID-19早期浪潮可能对低手术量医院产生了不成比例的影响。然而,2018年至2022年期间所有三组CD≥3并发症的SMRs下降表明日本直肠癌手术服务的稳健性和恢复力。医院之间短期结局的潜在差异是一个新的关注点。