van den Beuken Meike, Loos Isis, Maas Esther, Stunt Jonáh, Kuijper Lothar
Department of Health Sciences, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Menzies Institute for Medical Research, University of Tasmania, Hobart, Australia.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 May 19;25(1):724. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07289-2.
Soft skill development is of growing importance in higher education. However, the definitions of soft skills are unclear and soft skill development and assessment in higher education are underexplored. Therefore, the research question of this study is as follows: What are the experiences of teaching staff and students of the bachelor's internship in health sciences regarding soft skills development and assessment?
For this qualitative study, using a phenomenological approach, sixteen participants (ten university teachers and six bachelor students) were interviewed via semi structured interviews, based on the theoretical framework of Nicol & Macfarlane's model of self-regulation. The results were analysed through thematic analysis.
The experiences of soft skills were divided into eight themes related to development and assessment. In terms of development, it is [1] important to show a growth in soft skills. This development depends on [2] the perceived guidance provided by teachers [3], the type of internships, and [4] the perceived supervision in soft skills. Regarding assessment [5], teachers often struggle to evaluate soft skills, highlighting [6] the need for durable assessment of soft skills. Additionally [7], both students and teachers feel a need for more focus on soft skills in education. Furthermore [8], several prior factors, such as acknowledgement of soft skills and self-reflection skills, are mentioned to optimise student development.
This study highlights the importance of soft skills development and assessment in higher education. A clear definition of soft skills is recommended. Our findings demonstrate how teachers struggle with their role in soft skills supervision and assessment, with the consequence that students experience a lack of supervision and assessment in soft skills development.
软技能发展在高等教育中日益重要。然而,软技能的定义尚不明确,高等教育中的软技能发展与评估也未得到充分探索。因此,本研究的研究问题如下:健康科学专业本科实习的教师和学生在软技能发展与评估方面有哪些经验?
在Nicol和Macfarlane的自我调节模型这一理论框架的基础上,本定性研究采用现象学方法,通过半结构化访谈对16名参与者(10名大学教师和6名本科学生)进行了访谈。通过主题分析对结果进行了分析。
软技能的经验分为与发展和评估相关的八个主题。在发展方面,软技能的成长很重要。这种发展取决于[1]教师提供的可感知指导[2]、实习类型[3]以及软技能方面的可感知监督[4]。在评估方面[5],教师在评估软技能时往往感到困难,这突出了[6]对软技能进行持续评估的必要性。此外[7],学生和教师都认为在教育中需要更多地关注软技能。此外[8],还提到了一些先前的因素,如对软技能的认可和自我反思技能,以优化学生的发展。
本研究强调了高等教育中软技能发展与评估的重要性。建议对软技能进行明确的定义。我们的研究结果表明了教师在软技能监督和评估中的角色困境,其结果是学生在软技能发展中缺乏监督和评估。