Suppr超能文献

荷兰儿科姑息治疗临床实践指南:关于心理社会护理(包括丧亲前护理和哀伤护理)的系统评价与建议

A Dutch clinical practice guideline for paediatric palliative care: a systematic review and recommendations on psychosocial care including preloss and bereavement care.

作者信息

van Teunenbroek Kim C, Mulder Renée L, Verhagen A A Eduard, Kremer Leontien C M, Falkenburg Jeanette L, Honig-Mazer Petra, van den Bergh Esther M M, Kars Marijke C, Verheijden Johannes M A, Rippen Hester, Borggreve Brigitt C M, Kochen Eline M, Michiels Erna M C

机构信息

Princess Máxima Centre for Paediatric Oncology, Utrecht, The Netherlands.

Department of Pediatrics, Beatrix Children's Hospital, University Medical Centre Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, the Netherlands.

出版信息

BMC Palliat Care. 2025 May 23;24(1):147. doi: 10.1186/s12904-025-01763-w.

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Children with life-threatening and life-limiting conditions and their families are confronted with many uncertainties, incremental losses, and difficult decisions. Attentiveness to psychosocial care, including psychological, social, and spiritual concerns, is essential during the child's life until end-of-life and during bereavement and determines quality of life and wellbeing of child and family. However, use and integration of psychosocial care is found to be challenging. In this paper, we provide recommendations that aim to optimise psychosocial care including preloss and bereavement care in paediatric palliative care.

METHODS

A multidisciplinary guideline development panel of 25 experts in paediatric palliative care and nine parents was established to develop recommendations on psychosocial care including preloss and bereavement care. We performed a systematic literature search to identify evidence focussing on effectivity of interventions described in systematic reviews (SRs) of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and RCTs. From the search, we also derived evidence from SRs of observational, qualitative, or mixed-method studies on preloss and bereavement care. The GRADE methodology was used for appraising evidence. We used existing guidelines to deal with lack of evidence. Recommendations were formulated based on evidence, existing guidelines, clinical expertise, and patient and family values.

RESULTS

We identified a total two SRs of RCTs and six RCTs that reported on the effect of psychological interventions, spiritual support interventions, and bereavement care intervention. The evidence showed that only some of the interventions improve certain psychosocial outcomes in children or parents. We were unable to draw conclusions on which intervention is most effective, due to the high variability in interventions and measured outcomes. The evidence from ten SRs of observational, qualitative, or mixed-method studies was used as a basis for preloss and bereavement care recommendations. In total, we formulated 48 recommendations.

DISCUSSION

With the provided recommendations, we aim to optimise psychosocial care for children with life-threatening and life-limiting conditions and their families. Psychosocial care should be tailored to the child and family. We found a lack of evidence on psychosocial care including preloss and bereavement care. Although very challenging, we propose implementing strategies to improve research and thereby further optimise quality of paediatric palliative care. These strategies include the development of a standard set of outcomes and to conduct well-designed multisite RCTs.

摘要

背景

患有危及生命和限制生命状况的儿童及其家庭面临许多不确定性、逐渐增加的损失以及艰难的决策。在儿童生命直至临终阶段以及丧亲期间,关注心理社会护理,包括心理、社会和精神方面的问题,对于决定儿童及其家庭的生活质量和幸福感至关重要。然而,心理社会护理的使用和整合具有挑战性。在本文中,我们提供了旨在优化心理社会护理的建议,包括儿科姑息治疗中的丧亲前护理和丧亲护理。

方法

成立了一个由25名儿科姑息治疗专家和9名家长组成的多学科指南制定小组,以制定关于心理社会护理(包括丧亲前护理和丧亲护理)的建议。我们进行了系统的文献检索,以确定侧重于随机对照试验(RCT)和RCT的系统评价(SR)中描述的干预措施有效性的证据。从检索中,我们还从关于丧亲前护理和丧亲护理的观察性、定性或混合方法研究的SR中获取证据。采用GRADE方法评估证据。我们使用现有指南来处理证据不足的情况。根据证据、现有指南、临床专业知识以及患者和家庭价值观制定建议。

结果

我们总共确定了两项RCT的SR和六项报告心理干预、精神支持干预和丧亲护理干预效果的RCT。证据表明,只有一些干预措施能改善儿童或家长的某些心理社会结局。由于干预措施和测量结局的高度变异性,我们无法得出哪种干预措施最有效的结论。来自十项观察性、定性或混合方法研究的SR的证据被用作丧亲前护理和丧亲护理建议的基础。我们总共制定了48条建议。

讨论

通过提供的建议,我们旨在优化对患有危及生命和限制生命状况的儿童及其家庭的心理社会护理。心理社会护理应根据儿童和家庭的情况量身定制。我们发现缺乏关于包括丧亲前护理和丧亲护理在内的心理社会护理的证据。尽管极具挑战性,但我们建议实施改善研究的策略,从而进一步优化儿科姑息治疗的质量。这些策略包括制定一套标准结局,并开展设计良好的多中心RCT。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验