Haley Colin M, Escontrías Omar A, Sun Qin, Schwartz Scott B
Office of Academic Affairs, University of Illinois Chicago College of Dentistry, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
ConTrías Policy Associates, Washington, District of Columbia, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2025 May;89(5):731-742. doi: 10.1002/jdd.13709.
PURPOSE/OBJECTIVES: The study aims to examine the perceptions and experiences of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and queer (LGBQ+) faculty, administrators, and staff regarding campus climate in the United States and Canadian dental schools and allied dental education programs. This research focuses on sexual orientation, excluding gender identity, to provide a clearer understanding of LGBQ+ experiences in academic dentistry.
The American Dental Education Association climate study survey was conducted from January to March 2022 across dental schools and allied dental education programs in the United States and Canada. An independent ethical review board approved the survey. Data were collected from faculty, administrators, and staff who identified as LGBQ+ or heterosexual. The survey responses were analyzed using chi-square tests and proportional odds models to compare the experiences of LGBQ+ respondents with their heterosexual counterparts.
The study included 162 administrators, 1274 faculty, and 326 staff from allied dental schools, and 641 administrators, 2752 faculty, and 2270 staff from dental schools. Key findings indicate that LGBQ+ respondents were less likely to feel a sense of belonging, perceive a humanistic environment, or be satisfied with diversity programs. They were also more likely to report experiences of discrimination and harassment. The study identified significant disparities in perceptions of leadership commitment to diversity and inclusivity between LGBQ+ and heterosexual respondents.
The findings highlight the need for dental education institutions to enhance efforts in fostering a supportive and inclusive environment for LGBQ+ faculty, administrators, and staff. Recommendations include improving community-building activities, promoting a humanistic environment, revising hiring practices, implementing zero-tolerance policies for discrimination and harassment, and increasing awareness and engagement in Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion initiatives. Addressing these issues is crucial for improving the overall climate and ensuring the well-being and productivity of LGBQ+ individuals in academic dentistry.
目的/目标:本研究旨在调查女同性恋、男同性恋、双性恋和酷儿(LGBQ+)教职员工、管理人员和工作人员对美国和加拿大牙科学院及相关牙科教育项目校园氛围的看法和经历。本研究聚焦于性取向,不包括性别认同,以便更清晰地了解LGBQ+群体在牙科学术领域的经历。
2022年1月至3月,在美国和加拿大的牙科学院及相关牙科教育项目中开展了美国牙科教育协会氛围研究调查。该调查获得了独立伦理审查委员会的批准。数据收集自自认为是LGBQ+或异性恋的教职员工、管理人员和工作人员。使用卡方检验和比例优势模型对调查回复进行分析,以比较LGBQ+受访者与异性恋受访者的经历。
该研究纳入了来自相关牙科学院的162名管理人员、1274名教职员工和326名工作人员,以及来自牙科学院的641名管理人员、2752名教职员工和2270名工作人员。主要研究结果表明,LGBQ+受访者归属感较低、对人文环境的感知较差,对多元化项目的满意度也较低。他们还更有可能报告遭受歧视和骚扰的经历。该研究发现,LGBQ+受访者与异性恋受访者在对领导层对多元化和包容性承诺的看法上存在显著差异。
研究结果凸显出牙科教育机构需要加大力度,为LGBQ+教职员工、管理人员和工作人员营造一个支持性和包容性的环境。建议包括加强社区建设活动、营造人文环境、修订招聘做法、实施对歧视和骚扰的零容忍政策,以及提高对多元化、公平和包容倡议的认识并参与其中。解决这些问题对于改善整体氛围、确保LGBQ+群体在牙科学术领域的福祉和工作效率至关重要。