Yi Tianfei, Zhang Junfeng, Shen Peng, Sun Yexiang
Yinzhou District Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Ningbo, Zhejiang, China.
Front Public Health. 2025 May 14;13:1593102. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1593102. eCollection 2025.
Acute respiratory infection syndromes (ARIs) pose major public health challenges due to their high infectivity, rapid transmission, and the lack of standardized definitions balancing sensitivity and specificity in current surveillance systems.
Using data from Yinzhou Regional Health Information Platform (YRHIP), we refined ARIs definition, improved classical epidemic criteria and designed a comprehensive graded early-warning model to enhance early response capabilities.
We optimized ARIs definition based on laboratory-confirmed cases and evaluating screening performance with clinical diagnoses. Anomaly detection methods, including historical limits method (HLM), moving percentile method (MPM), cumulative sum control chart (CUSUM), and exponentially weighted moving average (EWMA), were employed to develop a graded early-warning model. Syndrome selection and parameter tuning were guided by Youden's index, agreement rate and F1-score.
The refined ARIs definition includes: Acute-phase fever with at least one typical respiratory symptoms; or acute-phase fever with at least two atypical respiratory symptoms; or at least one typical respiratory symptoms combined with at least two atypical respiratory symptoms. Furthermore, we demonstrate that ARIs outperform ILIs definition in early screening due to their broader symptom scope. By leveraging multidimensional time series data, we developed a robust epidemic criteria framework for early-warning models. The optimal early-warning parameters included configurations of HLM ( = 0.8), MPM (85th percentile), CUSUM( = 0.7, = 5), and EWMA ( = 3, = 0.05). The graded early-warning system revealed: Red early-warnings (all four models triggered) had the highest specificity; Orange early-warnings (at least three models triggered) demonstrated the best overall performance; Amber early-warnings (at least two models triggered) captured subtle trends; Green early-warnings (at least one model triggered) provided the highest sensitivity.
This study establishes an optimized, multi-model-based framework for ARIs early-warning that balances sensitivity and specificity to strengthen public health management against diverse pathogens.
急性呼吸道感染综合征(ARIs)因其高传染性、快速传播以及当前监测系统中缺乏平衡敏感性和特异性的标准化定义,对公共卫生构成重大挑战。
利用鄞州区域卫生信息平台(YRHIP)的数据,我们完善了ARIs的定义,改进了经典的流行标准,并设计了一个综合分级预警模型,以提高早期应对能力。
我们基于实验室确诊病例优化了ARIs的定义,并通过临床诊断评估筛查性能。采用异常检测方法,包括历史界限法(HLM)、移动百分位数法(MPM)、累积和控制图(CUSUM)和指数加权移动平均(EWMA),来开发分级预警模型。综合征的选择和参数调整以约登指数、一致率和F1分数为指导。
完善后的ARIs定义包括:急性期发热并伴有至少一种典型呼吸道症状;或急性期发热并伴有至少两种非典型呼吸道症状;或至少一种典型呼吸道症状与至少两种非典型呼吸道症状同时出现。此外,我们证明,由于ARIs的症状范围更广,在早期筛查中其表现优于流感样疾病(ILI)的定义。通过利用多维度时间序列数据,我们为预警模型开发了一个强大的流行标准框架。最佳预警参数包括HLM(=0.8)、MPM(第85百分位数)、CUSUM(=0.7,=5)和EWMA(=3,=0.05)的配置。分级预警系统显示:红色预警(所有四个模型触发)具有最高的特异性;橙色预警(至少三个模型触发)表现出最佳的整体性能;黄色预警(至少两个模型触发)捕捉到细微趋势;绿色预警(至少一个模型触发)提供最高的敏感性。
本研究建立了一个优化的、基于多模型的ARIs预警框架,平衡了敏感性和特异性,以加强针对多种病原体的公共卫生管理。