Yaïci Rémi, Mirr Małgorzata, Solecki Lauriana, Koestel Emilia, Bazarya Eugénie, Dhubhghaill Sorcha Ní, Sanogo Massira, Lefebvre François, Aclimandos Wagih, Asoklis Rimvydas, Atilla Huban, Creuzot-Garcher Catherine, Curtin Denise, Cvenkel Barbara, Flanagan Lisa, Kivelä Tero T, Maino Anna, Costa Rafael Martinez, Filipe Helena Prior, Strong Brendan, Tassignon Marie José, Ivekovic Renata, Priglinger Siegfried, Sturmer Joerg, Stopa Marcin, Bourcier Tristan
Department of Ophthalmology, Strasbourg University Hospital, NHC, University of Strasbourg, Strasbourg, BP426, 67091, France.
Department of Ophthalmology, Chair of Ophthalmology and Optometry, Poznan University of Medical Sciences, Poznan University Hospital, Poznan, Poland.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 May 29;25(1):796. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07282-9.
BACKGROUNDS/OBJECTIVES: This study, part of a series, aims to present and analyze the results of the Polish cohort in a European Board of Ophthalmology (EBO) survey on cataract surgical (CS) training in Europe, highlighting national traits and contributing to the discussion on standardizing ophthalmology training.
This study analyses the survey results of Polish participants in the EBO examinations (2018-2022) and compared them with the largest groups of candidates (Germany, France, Swiss and Spain).
Out of 144 candidates, 79 (55%) answered the questionnaire. Most (70.9%) had taken the EBO exam between 2021 and 2022, with the vast majority of study participants being women (77.2%) with a median age of 34 years and came from 9 different voivodeships. Notably, 25.4% stated that they had carried out 10 or more training sessions on virtual reality simulator, 13.9% on synthetic eyes and 12.7% on animal eyes. There was a significant difference in the concrete use of SBME (more than ten sessions regardless of the simulation tool) between men and women (55.6% versus 23% respectively, p = 0.008). A notable discrepancy was observed between participants with 10 or more training sessions and those without specific training in four key areas: self-assessed confidence and ability to perform cataract surgery (p = 0.003), handling complications like posterior capsular tear (p < 0.001) and in performing corneal sutures (p = 0.015). Less than half (40.5%) of respondents had not performed any steps of cataract surgery on patients during their residency. Unlike in the EBO results, there were no gender differences found.
The results show a geographically homogenous group with an overrepresentation of Warsaw. Polish residency training is a hybrid model ensuring that all residents receive uniform surgical training. After completing their residency, Polish ophthalmologists are subsequently categorized into either surgical specialists or clinical practitioners.
背景/目的:本研究作为系列研究的一部分,旨在呈现并分析欧洲眼科委员会(EBO)关于欧洲白内障手术(CS)培训调查中波兰队列的结果,突出国家特点,并为眼科培训标准化的讨论做出贡献。
本研究分析了波兰参与者在EBO考试(2018 - 2022年)中的调查结果,并将其与最大的候选人群体(德国、法国、瑞士和西班牙)进行比较。
在144名候选人中,79人(55%)回答了问卷。大多数(70.9%)在2021年至2022年期间参加了EBO考试,绝大多数研究参与者为女性(77.2%),中位年龄为34岁,来自9个不同的省。值得注意的是,25.4%的人表示他们在虚拟现实模拟器上进行了10次或更多的培训课程,13.9%在合成眼上进行培训,12.7%在动物眼上进行培训。男性和女性在基于模拟病例的医学教育(SBME)的具体使用情况(无论模拟工具如何,超过十次培训课程)上存在显著差异(分别为55.6%和23%,p = 0.008)。在四个关键领域,接受过10次或更多培训课程的参与者与未接受过特定培训的参与者之间存在显著差异:自我评估的白内障手术信心和能力(p = 0.003)、处理后囊膜撕裂等并发症的能力(p < 0.001)以及角膜缝合操作能力(p = 0.015)。不到一半(40.5%)的受访者在住院医师培训期间没有对患者进行过任何白内障手术步骤。与EBO的结果不同,未发现性别差异。
结果显示这是一个地域分布较为集中、华沙地区占比过高的群体。波兰的住院医师培训是一种混合模式,可确保所有住院医师接受统一的外科手术培训。完成住院医师培训后,波兰眼科医生随后被分为外科专家或临床从业者两类。