Yaïci Rémi, Khamsy Lilly, Potic Jelena, Dhubhghaill Sorcha Ní, Sanogo Massira, Lefebvre François, Aclimandos Wagih, Asoklis Rimvydas, Atilla Huban, Creuzot-Garcher Catherine, Curtin Denise, Cvenkel Barbara, Flanagan Lisa, Kivelä Tero T, Maino Anna, Costa Rafael Martinez, Filipe Helena Prior, Stopa Marcin, Strong Brendan, Tassignon Marie José, Ivekovic Renata, Priglinger Siegfried, Sturmer Joerg, Bourcier Tristan
Department of Ophthalmology, Strasbourg University Hospital, NHC, University of Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France.
Young Swiss Ophthalmologists, Basel, Switzerland.
Eur J Ophthalmol. 2025 Jul;35(4):1169-1178. doi: 10.1177/11206721241304052. Epub 2024 Dec 12.
IntroductionThis study, part of a series, analyses the Swiss cohort from an EBO survey on cataract surgery training in Europe, focusing on Switzerland's unique program. The survey identifies two models: training all residents in surgery, and a "high-volume surgeon" model where only some learn CS post-residency.MethodsThis study analyses the survey results of Swiss participants in the EBO examinations (2018-2022) and compared them with the most important cohorts (Germany, France and Spain).ResultsOut of 251 respondents, 87 (34.7%) answered the questionnaire. Most (70.1%) had taken the EBO exam between 2021-2022, with the majority of study participants being men (55.2%) with a median age of 34 years and came from 12 different cantons. Two third (68.8%) of respondents had not performed any steps of cataract surgery on patients during their residency. Notably, 22.1% stated that they had carried out 10 or more training sessions on virtual reality simulator, 5.8% on synthetic eyes and 21% on animal eyes. A notable discrepancy was observed between participants with 10 or more training sessions and those without specific training in four key areas: self-assessed confidence and ability to perform cataract surgery (p = 0.006), management of challenging cases (p = 0.027), handling complications like posterior capsular tear (p = 0.031) and in performing corneal sutures (p = 0.023).DiscussionSwitzerland fits into the "high-volume surgeon" model group; extensive simulation-based training there significantly boosts self-confidence in performing CS, an effect less noticeable in countries offering hands-on training during residency.
引言
本研究是系列研究的一部分,分析了欧洲白内障手术培训EBO调查中的瑞士队列,重点关注瑞士独特的培训项目。该调查确定了两种模式:对所有住院医师进行手术培训,以及“高手术量外科医生”模式,即只有部分人在住院医师培训后学习白内障手术。
方法
本研究分析了瑞士参与者在EBO考试(2018 - 2022年)中的调查结果,并将其与最重要的队列(德国、法国和西班牙)进行比较。
结果
在251名受访者中,87人(34.7%)回答了问卷。大多数(70.1%)在2021 - 2022年参加了EBO考试,研究参与者多数为男性(55.2%),中位年龄为34岁,来自12个不同的州。三分之二(68.8%)的受访者在住院医师培训期间未对患者进行过任何白内障手术步骤。值得注意的是,22.1%的人表示他们在虚拟现实模拟器上进行了10次或更多的培训课程,5.8%在合成眼上进行培训,21%在动物眼上进行培训。在四个关键领域,接受10次或更多培训课程的参与者与未接受特定培训的参与者之间存在显著差异:自我评估的白内障手术信心和能力(p = 0.006)、复杂病例的管理(p = 0.027)、处理后囊膜撕裂等并发症(p = 0.031)以及进行角膜缝合(p = 0.023)。
讨论
瑞士属于“高手术量外科医生”模式组;那里基于模拟的广泛培训显著提高了进行白内障手术的自信心,这一效果在住院医师培训期间提供实践培训的国家不太明显。