痴呆症在获得医疗服务、护理质量和治疗效果方面的性别差异:截至2024年的研究范围综述

Sex and gender differences in access, quality of care, and effectiveness of treatment in dementia: a scoping review of studies up to 2024.

作者信息

Aguzzoli Elisa, Walbaum Magdalena, Knapp Martin, Castro-Aldrete Laura, Santuccione Chadha Antonella, Cyhlarova Eva

机构信息

Care Policy and Evaluation Centre, London, School of Economics and Political Science, London, WC2A 2AE, UK.

Women's Brain Foundation, 4052, Basel, Switzerland.

出版信息

Arch Public Health. 2025 May 29;83(1):139. doi: 10.1186/s13690-025-01626-z.

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Dementia represents one of the greatest global health challenges. Women have a greater lifetime risk of developing dementia compared to men. Both pharmacological and non-pharmacological interventions aimed at slowing cognitive decline show promising results. However, most studies do not examine whether there are sex and gender differences in access to treatment, quality of care or treatment effectiveness.

OBJECTIVES

To summarise evidence on sex and gender differences in access to treatment, management, and treatment effectiveness for people with dementia.

METHODS

This scoping review followed PRISMA guidelines and was conducted in PubMed/MEDLINE, EMBASE, Google Scholar, and ClinicalTrials.Gov databases in November 2023 and updated in January 2024. Systematic reviews and observational studies were included to explore sex and gender differences in access or management of dementia. Systematic reviews and clinical trials were included to investigate sex and gender differences in treatment effectiveness.

RESULTS

We included 16 studies in our review. Sex and gender differences were observed in the prescription and receipt of anti-dementia medications, as well as access to primary care, with variations by settings. Mixed results were found concerning polypharmacy and inappropriate medications, with women being prescribed antipsychotic and other psychotropic medications for longer periods compared to men. Studies of the impact of exercise on cognitive decline yielded mixed results, though limited disaggregated data by sex indicated a more pronounced impact in women than in men. Cognitive stimulation therapy interventions showed greater cognitive improvements for women. Clinical trials assessing the effectiveness of disease-modifying therapies (DMTs) suggest that women may be less responsive to DMTs than men.

CONCLUSIONS

There are important differences between men and women living with dementia in access to diagnosis, treatments, quality of care and effectiveness of treatments. Such differences can significantly impact health outcomes. Sex and gender inequalities should be considered when planning and implementing healthcare, social care, and associated strategies in dementia. To provide conclusive evidence, it is essential for clinical trials to have sufficient statistical power and report outcomes disaggregated by sex.

摘要

背景

痴呆症是全球最大的健康挑战之一。与男性相比,女性一生中患痴呆症的风险更高。旨在减缓认知衰退的药物和非药物干预措施均显示出有希望的结果。然而,大多数研究并未考察在获得治疗、护理质量或治疗效果方面是否存在性别差异。

目的

总结痴呆症患者在获得治疗、管理及治疗效果方面的性别差异证据。

方法

本范围综述遵循PRISMA指南,于2023年11月在PubMed/MEDLINE、EMBASE、谷歌学术和ClinicalTrials.Gov数据库中进行,并于2024年1月更新。纳入系统评价和观察性研究以探讨痴呆症患者在获得治疗或管理方面的性别差异。纳入系统评价和临床试验以研究治疗效果方面的性别差异。

结果

我们的综述纳入了16项研究。在抗痴呆药物的处方和使用以及获得初级保健方面观察到了性别差异,且因环境不同而有所变化。在多重用药和不适当用药方面发现了混合结果,与男性相比,女性使用抗精神病药物和其他精神药物的时间更长。关于运动对认知衰退影响的研究结果不一,不过按性别分类的数据有限,表明运动对女性的影响比男性更显著。认知刺激疗法干预对女性的认知改善更大。评估疾病修饰疗法(DMTs)有效性的临床试验表明,女性对DMTs的反应可能比男性更差。

结论

痴呆症患者在获得诊断、治疗、护理质量和治疗效果方面存在重要的性别差异。这些差异会对健康结果产生重大影响。在规划和实施痴呆症的医疗保健、社会护理及相关策略时,应考虑性别不平等问题。为提供确凿证据,临床试验必须有足够的统计效力并报告按性别分类的结果。

https://cdn.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/blobs/d46b/12121192/22b83c0a20b8/13690_2025_1626_Fig1_HTML.jpg

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索