Yang Zhiqing, Choe Youngjun, Martell Matthew
Department of Statistics, University of Washington, United States.
Information School, University of Washington, United States.
J Saf Sci Resil. 2021 Dec;2(4):230-237. doi: 10.1016/j.jnlssr.2021.09.003. Epub 2021 Oct 5.
To battle with economic challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic, the US government implemented various measures to mitigate economic loss. From issuance of stimulus checks to reopening businesses, consumers had to constantly alter their behavior in response to government policies. Using anonymized card transactions and mobile device-based location tracking data, we analyze the factors that contribute to these behavior changes, focusing on stimulus check issuance and state-wide reopening. Our finding suggests that stimulus payment has a significant immediate effect of boosting spending, but it typically does not reverse a downward trend. State-wide reopening had a small effect on spending. Foot traffic increased gradually after stimulus check issuance, but only increased slightly after reopening, which also coincided or preceded several policy changes and confounding events (e.g., protests) in the US. We also find differences in the reaction to these policies in different regions in the US. Our results may be used to inform future economic recovery policies and their potential consumer response.
为应对新冠疫情期间的经济挑战,美国政府实施了多项措施以减轻经济损失。从发放刺激支票到重新开放企业,消费者不得不根据政府政策不断改变自己的行为。我们利用匿名卡交易和基于移动设备的位置跟踪数据,分析导致这些行为变化的因素,重点关注刺激支票的发放和全州范围的重新开放。我们的研究结果表明,刺激付款对促进支出有显著的即时影响,但通常不会扭转下降趋势。全州范围的重新开放对支出的影响较小。在发放刺激支票后,人流量逐渐增加,但重新开放后仅略有增加,而这也恰逢或早于美国的几项政策变化和混杂事件(如抗议活动)。我们还发现美国不同地区对这些政策的反应存在差异。我们的研究结果可用于为未来的经济复苏政策及其潜在的消费者反应提供参考。