Squizzato Francesco, Piazza Michele, Piffaretti Gabriele, Gatta Emanuele, Tshomba Yamume, Orrico Matteo, Ronchey Sonia, Bozzani Antonio, Pratesi Giovanni, Gaggiano Andrea, Simonte Gioele, Mansour Wassim, Antonello Michele
Division of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery, Department of Cardiac, Thoracic, Vascular Sciences and Public Health, University of Padua, Padua, Italy.
Division of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery, Department of Cardiac, Thoracic, Vascular Sciences and Public Health, University of Padua, Padua, Italy.
J Vasc Surg. 2025 Jun 4. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2025.05.036.
To report the impact of the learning curve on the outcomes of branched endovascular aortic repair using an off-the-shelf preloaded inner branch device (E-nside).
Data from a physician-initiated national multicenter registry, including patients treated with E-nside endograft (INBREED [ItaliaN Branch Registry of E-nside EnDograft]) were collected prospectively (2020-2024). End points were early (30-day) technical success, mortality, major adverse events (MAEs), and 2-year freedom from endograft instability and target vessel instability. Patients were divided into early and late cohorts based on the median date of the procedure in each center.
There were 215 patients treated with the E-nside, 108 (393 target vessels) in the early and 107 (395 target vessels) in the late cohort. Most patients had a degenerative aneurysm (early, 82%; late, 75%; P = .326) or a chronic dissection (early, 6%; late, 15%; P = .025). Aneurysm extent was thoracoabdominal in 53% of patients and complex abdominal in 47%; and 23% were ruptured or symptomatic and 26% had an aneurysm size of more than 70 mm, without differences between groups. A narrow paravisceral aortic lumen of less than 25 mm was more frequent in the late cohort (late, 30%; early, 18%; P = .037). From the early to the late groups, there was an increase in the use of a total transfemoral approach (late, 29% vs early, 18%; P = .042), balloon-expandable bridging stents (late, 82% vs early, 76%; P = .032), and reinforcement bridging stents (late, 26%; early, 11%; P < .001). Operating time (late, 267 ± 131 minutes; early, 244 ± 130 minutes; P = .230), iodinated contrast volume (late, 181 ± 81 mL; early, 210 ± 141 mL; P = 108; P = .302), and dose area product (late, 272 ± 110 Gycm early, 291 ± 118 Gycm; P = .277) were similar in the two groups. Intraprocedural complications decreased in the later stage of the learning curve (late, 11%; early, 23%; P = .030), whereas overall 30-day mortality (late, 8%; early, 6%; P = .346), technical success (late, 99%; early, 98%; P = .286), and MAEs (late, 27%; early, 29%; P = .879) remained substantially stable. There were no differences in 2-year freedom from endograft instability (late, 100 ± 0%; early, 96 ± 5%; P = 1.00), freedom from target vessel instability (late, 98 ± 3%; early, 94 ± 2%; P = .090), and target vessel primary patency (late, 97 ± 2%; early, 97 ± 2%; P = .321).
The increased experience with the E-nside endograft was associated with a more frequent use of a total transfemoral approach and use of balloon-expandable and reinforced bridging stents. From the early to the late stages, there was a significant decrease in intraoperative complications, although most centers were learning independent and achieved a consistent mortality, MAE, procedural metrics, and mid-term results from the start.
报告学习曲线对使用现成预装内分支装置(E-nside)进行分支型血管腔内主动脉修复术结果的影响。
前瞻性收集(2020 - 2024年)来自一项由医生发起的全国多中心注册研究的数据,包括接受E-nside血管内移植物治疗的患者(INBREED [意大利E-nside血管内移植物分支注册研究])。终点指标为早期(30天)技术成功率、死亡率、主要不良事件(MAE)以及2年内移植物稳定性和靶血管稳定性情况。根据各中心手术日期的中位数将患者分为早期和晚期队列。
共有215例患者接受了E-nside治疗,早期队列108例(393条靶血管),晚期队列107例(395条靶血管)。大多数患者患有退行性动脉瘤(早期82%,晚期75%;P = 0.326)或慢性夹层(早期6%,晚期15%;P = 0.025)。53%的患者动脉瘤累及胸腹段,47%为复杂腹段;23%为破裂或有症状的动脉瘤,26%的动脉瘤直径超过70 mm,两组间无差异。晚期队列中腹主动脉旁管腔狭窄小于25 mm更为常见(晚期30%,早期18%;P = 0.037)。从早期组到晚期组,经股动脉入路(晚期29% vs早期18%;P = 0.042)、球囊扩张式桥接支架(晚期82% vs早期76%;P = 0.032)和加强型桥接支架(晚期26%,早期11%;P < 0.001)的使用有所增加。两组的手术时间(晚期267±131分钟,早期244±130分钟;P = 0.230)、碘造影剂用量(晚期181±81 mL,早期210±141 mL;P = 0.108;P = 0.302)和剂量面积乘积(晚期272±110 Gycm,早期291±118 Gycm;P = 0.277)相似。学习曲线后期术中并发症有所减少(晚期11%,早期23%;P = 0.030),而30天总体死亡率(晚期8%,早期6%;P = 0.346)、技术成功率(晚期99%,早期98%;P = 0.286)和主要不良事件(晚期27%,早期29%;P = 0.879)基本保持稳定。2年内移植物稳定性(晚期100±0%,早期96±5%;P = 1.00)、靶血管稳定性(晚期98±3%,早期94±2%;P = 0.090)和靶血管初始通畅率(晚期97±2%,早期97±2%;P = 0.321)方面无差异。
随着对E-nside血管内移植物经验的增加,经股动脉入路以及球囊扩张式和加强型桥接支架的使用更为频繁。从早期到晚期阶段,术中并发症显著减少,尽管大多数中心是独立学习,且从一开始就实现了一致的死亡率、主要不良事件、手术指标和中期结果。