Chauhan Bhanu Pratap Singh, Hedaoo Ketan, Parihar Vijay, Bajaj Jitin, Ratre Shailendra, Sinha Mallika, Swamy M N, Sharma Mukesh, Patidar Jayant, Yadav Y R
Department of Neurosurgery, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bilaspur, Himachal Pradesh, India.
Department of Neurosurgery, Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose Medical College, Jabalpur, Madhya Pradesh, India.
Asian J Neurosurg. 2025 Mar 18;20(2):350-356. doi: 10.1055/s-0045-1805087. eCollection 2025 Jun.
In recent times, the supraorbital approach via eyebrow incision has gained tremendous popularity in targeting the anterior skull base and few middle cranial fossa lesions, over the more traditional pterional and frontotemporal approaches. However, the extremely narrow viewing angle through this approach requires frequent adjustments of the operating table and microscope for optimal visualization. Illumination via such a small opening in such deep-seated location was another limiting factor. Keeping these problems and cumbersomeness of microscope in mind, experienced surgeons gradually shifted over to purely endoscopic or endoscope-assisted supraorbital keyhole approaches. But it was also limited due to high cost, steep learning curve, and difficulties faced in blood-filled cavities. To circumvent these limitations of the microscope and endoscope, the supraorbital keyhole approach can be accomplished with an exoscope (ExSOKHA). Although various cranial procedures using exoscope have become well established in contemporary times, there is paucity of studies and literature dedicated specifically to this minimally invasive supraorbital keyhole approach using the exoscope only. Here, we aim to study the feasibility and usefulness of the exoscope in targeting skull base lesions via the supraorbital keyhole approach to determine if it can be used in learning while transitioning from the microscope to the endoscope, with the primary objective being the user friendliness of the exoscope in the SOKHA technique. This prospective observational study was conducted in the department of neurosurgery over a period of 7 years. The sample size was 50. The study utilized an exoscope and support arm-2D VITOM rigid-lens telescope (Model 28095 VA, Karl Storz Endoscopy, Tuttlingen, Germany) with a 10-mm outer diameter and a shaft length of 14 cm, light source (Xenon Nova 300, Karl Storz GmBH and Co., Tuttlingen, Germany), camera head, video display monitor, and a holding arm. Out of 50 cases, the majority were pituitary adenomas (30%) and meningiomas (38%), with aneurysms comprising 6%; only 4 cases (8%) had inadvertent frontal sinus opening and 2 cases (4%) had postoperative cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak. The duration of surgery ranged from 2 to 4 hours, with the shortest being for aneurysm clipping/CSF rhinorrhea and the longest for meningioma and pituitary adenoma excision. Intraoperatively, exoscope repositioning for adjustment was required for a maximum of nine times, which significantly reduced the overall operative time. Eight cases had near total excision; the remaining tumors had complete excision and the aneurysms had complete clipping. Hospital stay ranged from 4 to 7 days, with mean intensive care unit (ICU) stay of 3 days. None of the patients had any surgical cosmetic deformity. The Glasgow Outcome Scale of all patients was good (4/5 or 5/5). Thus, ExSOKHA offered good results in terms of operative time, frequency of adjustments, completeness of excision and clipping, and recurrence. The results were also comparable for other parameters like inadvertent frontal sinus violation, postoperative CSF leak, hospital stay, cosmetic deformity, and outcome. The exoscope is a further advancement in the telescopic system, which provides a higher focal length (250-550 mm), ergonomically superior surgery with better depth illumination in skull base lesions approached via the supraorbital keyhole approach, significantly reducing operative time and improving resection margins due to increased corner visibility and easy maneuverability. It helps learn neuroendoscopy with the familiar principles of microneurosurgery, possibly shortening the learning curves. It bridges the gap between the endoscope and the microscope as the surgery is performed while viewing the screen (as in endoscope), but without needing to take the scope inside the operative field (as in microscope), making it easier to maneuver while also limiting space occupancy.
近年来,经眉弓切口的眶上入路在治疗前颅底及少数中颅窝病变方面比传统的翼点入路和额颞入路更受欢迎。然而,通过这种入路的视角极其狭窄,需要频繁调整手术台和显微镜以获得最佳视野。在如此深的位置通过如此小的开口进行照明是另一个限制因素。考虑到这些问题以及显微镜的繁琐操作,经验丰富的外科医生逐渐转向单纯内镜或内镜辅助眶上锁孔入路。但由于成本高、学习曲线陡峭以及在充满血液的腔隙中面临困难,其应用也受到限制。为了规避显微镜和内镜的这些局限性,可以使用外视镜(ExSOKHA)来完成眶上锁孔入路。尽管在当代,各种使用外视镜的颅脑手术已得到广泛应用,但专门针对仅使用外视镜的这种微创眶上锁孔入路的研究和文献却很少。在此,我们旨在研究外视镜通过眶上锁孔入路治疗颅底病变的可行性和实用性,以确定它是否可用于从显微镜过渡到内镜的学习过程中,主要目标是外视镜在眶上锁孔入路技术中的用户友好性。
这项前瞻性观察性研究在神经外科进行了七年。样本量为50例。该研究使用了一台外视镜和支持臂 - 2D VITOM刚性透镜望远镜(型号28095 VA,德国卡尔史托斯内窥镜公司)外径10毫米,镜杆长度14厘米,光源(氙气Nova 300,德国卡尔史托斯有限公司,图特林根),摄像头,视频显示监视器和一个固定臂。
在50例病例中,大多数是垂体腺瘤(30%)和脑膜瘤(38%),动脉瘤占6%;只有4例(8%)意外打开额窦,2例(4%)术后出现脑脊液漏。手术时间为2至4小时,最短的是动脉瘤夹闭/脑脊液鼻漏手术,最长的是脑膜瘤和垂体腺瘤切除术。术中,外视镜最多需要重新定位调整9次,这显著缩短了总体手术时间。8例实现了近全切;其余肿瘤均全切,动脉瘤夹闭完全。住院时间为4至7天,平均重症监护病房(ICU)住院时间为3天。所有患者均无手术导致的美容畸形。所有患者的格拉斯哥预后评分良好(4/5或5/5)。因此,ExSOKHA在手术时间、调整频率、切除和夹闭的完整性以及复发方面都取得了良好的效果。在意外侵犯额窦、术后脑脊液漏、住院时间、美容畸形和预后等其他参数方面,结果也具有可比性。
外视镜是望远镜系统的进一步发展,它提供了更高的焦距(250 - 550毫米),通过眶上锁孔入路治疗颅底病变时,在人体工程学上具有更优越的手术条件,深度照明更好,由于增加了角落视野和易于操作,显著减少了手术时间并改善了切除边缘。它有助于利用熟悉的显微神经外科原理学习神经内镜技术,可能缩短学习曲线。它弥合了内镜和显微镜之间的差距,因为手术是在观看屏幕时进行的(如在内镜手术中),但无需将内镜放入术野(如在显微镜手术中),使得操作更容易,同时也限制了空间占用。