Russolillo Angela
School of Nursing, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
Can J Public Health. 2025 Jun 9. doi: 10.17269/s41997-025-01065-x.
The unregulated drug crisis has raised growing concerns about the care and treatment of people experiencing complex mental health and substance use issues in British Columbia (BC). The BC government's recent plans for expansion of involuntary treatment across the province demonstrate a misguided understanding of mental health and substance use disorders. Relying on involuntary treatment as a primary response to this public health issue raises several ethical and clinical concerns. With the majority of evidence on involuntary treatment demonstrating limited effectiveness, and potential for increased harms, alternative evidence-based approaches are urgently needed. Addressing this public health challenge requires a shift away from involuntary treatment to person-centered, voluntary, integrated, and community-based solutions that address the social determinants of health. This commentary will review the limitations, clinical challenges, and policy alternatives to involuntary treatment of adults with substance use disorders.
不受监管的药物危机引发了人们对不列颠哥伦比亚省(BC)患有复杂心理健康和药物使用问题的人群的护理和治疗日益增长的担忧。BC省政府近期在全省范围内扩大非自愿治疗的计划表明了对心理健康和药物使用障碍的错误理解。将非自愿治疗作为应对这一公共卫生问题的主要手段引发了若干伦理和临床方面的担忧。鉴于大多数关于非自愿治疗的证据表明其效果有限,且存在造成更多伤害的可能性,迫切需要基于证据的替代方法。应对这一公共卫生挑战需要从非自愿治疗转向以个人为中心、自愿、综合且基于社区的解决方案,以解决健康的社会决定因素。本评论将审视对患有药物使用障碍的成年人进行非自愿治疗的局限性、临床挑战及政策替代方案。