Kirkham J L, Zamuner F, Cameron A W N, Leury B J, Carroll A, DiGiacomo K
School of Agriculture, Food and Ecosystem Sciences, Faculty of Science, The University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victoria 3010, Australia.
School of Agriculture, Food and Ecosystem Sciences, Faculty of Science, The University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victoria 3010, Australia.
J Dairy Sci. 2025 Aug;108(8):8449-8461. doi: 10.3168/jds.2025-26303. Epub 2025 Jun 9.
This experiment investigated the variability and repeatability of residual feed intake (RFI) in growing and lactating dairy goats, aiming to assess its potential as a selection tool for feed efficiency. During the growth phase, 5-mo-old Saanen doelings (n = 60) were grouped based on genetic potential for milk production: high-index (HI; n = 30) and low-index (LI; n = 30) doelings were used. During the lactation phase, 53 early-lactation does, also selected for HI and LI, were used. Of these 53 lactating does, 28 were from the growth phase to investigate the repeatability of RFI rankings. Individual feed intake, ADG, and BCS were recorded during both phases (49 d, plus 7-10 d acclimatization). On 4 occasions, plasma was collected for analysis of metabolic markers. During lactation, milk volume was recorded twice daily, and milk samples were collected twice per week for composition analysis. Goats were classified into high (<-0.5 SD from the mean of RFI), low (>+0.5 SD), and medium (between ± 0.5 SD), and efficiency groups based on RFI for both phases. The RFI variability was greater during lactation (-0.38 to 0.50 kg of DM/d) compared with growth (-0.16 to 0.17 kg of DM/d). During growth, high-efficiency goats consumed 0.18 kg/d less DM for similar production outcomes, with a mean DMI (±SD) of 1.1 ± 0.2 kg/d and an ADG of 226 ± 45 g/d. Lactating goats averaged (mean ± SD) a DMI of 2.6 ± 0.5 kg/d, ECM of 3.4 ± 0.8 kg/d, and an ADG of 139 ± 65 g/d, with high-efficiency goats maintaining reduced feed intake without compromising milk production. No significant correlation between RFI rankings in growth and lactation phases were observed, indicating limited repeatability in RFI ranking across life stages. The variability in RFI across growth and lactation, along with its independence from production traits, highlights its potential as a selection tool for improving feed efficiency in dairy goats. Further investigation into the causes of divergence in RFI and understanding the metabolic and physiological mechanisms is needed to define a more robust trait for selecting more feed-efficient animals.
本实验研究了生长和泌乳期奶山羊剩余采食量(RFI)的变异性和重复性,旨在评估其作为饲料效率选择工具的潜力。在生长阶段,根据产奶遗传潜力对5月龄的萨能母山羊(n = 60)进行分组:使用高指数(HI;n = 30)和低指数(LI;n = 30)的母山羊。在泌乳阶段,使用了53只同样按HI和LI选择的早期泌乳母羊。在这53只泌乳母羊中,有28只来自生长阶段,以研究RFI排名的重复性。在两个阶段(49天,外加7 - 10天适应期)记录个体采食量、平均日增重(ADG)和体况评分(BCS)。在4个时间点采集血浆用于代谢标志物分析。在泌乳期,每天记录两次产奶量,每周采集两次奶样进行成分分析。根据两个阶段的RFI将山羊分为高(RFI均值以下< - 0.5标准差)、低(RFI均值以上> + 0.5标准差)和中(± 0.5标准差之间)效率组。与生长阶段( - 0.16至0.17千克干物质/天)相比,泌乳期的RFI变异性更大( - 0.38至0.50千克干物质/天)。在生长阶段,高效山羊在生产结果相似的情况下,每天少消耗0.18千克干物质,平均干物质采食量(±标准差)为1.1 ± 0.2千克/天,ADG为226 ± 45克/天。泌乳母羊平均(均值±标准差)干物质采食量为2.6 ± 0.5千克/天,能量校正乳(ECM)为3.4 ± 0.8千克/天,ADG为139 ± 65克/天,高效母羊在不影响产奶量的情况下保持较低的采食量。未观察到生长阶段和泌乳阶段RFI排名之间存在显著相关性,表明RFI排名在不同生命阶段之间的重复性有限。生长和泌乳期RFI的变异性及其与生产性状的独立性,凸显了其作为提高奶山羊饲料效率选择工具的潜力。需要进一步研究RFI差异的原因,并了解代谢和生理机制,以确定一个更可靠的性状,用于选择更高效的动物。