Boye Bernard Okoe, Pokhrel Subhash, Cheung Kei Long, Anokye Nana
Department of Health Sciences, Brunel University London, Uxbridge, United Kingdom.
Front Public Health. 2025 May 29;13:1436098. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1436098. eCollection 2025.
This study explored the level of consensus on the drivers and barriers influencing doctors' decisions to work in rural versus urban areas. The study provides insights into systemic issues affecting healthcare workforce distribution in Ghana. Access to medical care is particularly important given the changing demographics of Ghana, including the growth of the older and chronically ill population and the high proportion of older adults living in rural areas.
A three-round e-Delphi study was conducted among doctors and regional directors of the Ghana Health Service using a seven-point Likert scale. A median score of ≥6 and an interquartile range of ≤1 was used as cutoffs. In total, 47 experts participated in the study. Although 55 initially registered interest, only 47 took part in the first round. By the second and third rounds, 42 experts remained engaged in the study.
Experts reached consensus on 40 descriptors (78%), of which 37 (93%) were considered important. Doctors reached consensus on 11 and 7 important drivers and barriers of rural incentive adoption, respectively, while reaching consensus on 8 important drivers of urban incentive factors. Regional directors reached consensus on 4 and 7 important drivers of rural and urban factors, respectively. Four categorical themes emerged from the analysis. These are financial, professional development and career advancement, work-life balance, and community lifestyle factors.
The contrast in drivers and barriers between rural and urban healthcare workers necessitates tailored policy approaches, resource allocation strategies, and workforce planning efforts to ensure equitable access and quality care across diverse settings and among different sub-populations, especially the growing number of aged and chronically ill.
本研究探讨了在影响医生选择在农村地区还是城市地区工作的驱动因素和障碍方面的共识水平。该研究深入了解了影响加纳医疗劳动力分布的系统性问题。鉴于加纳人口结构的变化,包括老年和慢性病患者人口的增长以及农村地区老年人的高比例,获得医疗服务尤为重要。
使用七点李克特量表对加纳卫生服务局的医生和地区主任进行了三轮电子德尔菲研究。以中位数得分≥6和四分位间距≤1作为临界值。共有47名专家参与了该研究。虽然最初有55人表示感兴趣,但只有47人参加了第一轮。到第二轮和第三轮时,仍有42名专家参与该研究。
专家们就40个描述符(78%)达成了共识,其中37个(93%)被认为是重要的。医生们分别就农村激励措施采用的11个和7个重要驱动因素及障碍达成了共识,同时就城市激励因素的8个重要驱动因素达成了共识。地区主任们分别就农村和城市因素的4个和7个重要驱动因素达成了共识。分析得出了四个分类主题。这些是财务、职业发展和职业晋升、工作与生活平衡以及社区生活方式因素。
农村和城市医护人员在驱动因素和障碍方面的差异需要有针对性的政策方法、资源分配策略和劳动力规划努力,以确保在不同环境和不同亚人群中,特别是在日益增多的老年人和慢性病患者中,能够公平获得医疗服务并获得高质量的护理。