Brown Megan E L, Burford Bryan, Price Christopher, Fu Yu, Vance Gillian
School of Medicine, Newcastle University, Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, UK.
Population Health Sciences Institute, Newcastle University, Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, UK.
Clin Teach. 2025 Aug;22(4):e70120. doi: 10.1111/tct.70120.
The Covid-19 pandemic placed unprecedented pressure on healthcare systems, education and individual professionals-notably, newly qualified front line nurses and paramedics. While we know wellbeing was negatively affected, qualitative exploration of workplace experiences and how these impact wellbeing and shape career decision making is lacking. This is a critical gap in the literature, given the current healthcare workforce crisis and a need for evidence-based educational reform to better support learners in the workplace. This study explores the experiences of nurses and paramedics during the pandemic and how these influenced wellbeing and career decision-making.
We adopted an interpretivist, qualitative approach, and conducted semi-structured interviews with seven newly qualified nurses and two senior paramedics. We utilised reflexive thematic analysis to explore and analyse data, considering the impact of starting work during Covid-19.
Our findings demonstrated the significant impact of the pandemic on wellbeing and career decision-making. Key issues included a turbulent transition into practice, shaped by increased clinical pressures (including high patient numbers, and workforce shortages) and reduced support at organisational and interpersonal levels. Participants described a shift in career values, with greater emphasis on wellbeing as a determinant for job decisions. Many reported re-evaluating their careers, prioritising roles or teams that offered better support and manageable workloads, or considering leaving healthcare altogether.
This study suggests a need for educational policy and practice to consider how workplace experience impacts wellbeing and career decision-making. Beyond indicating the need for further research, this study acts as a critical conversation regarding future workforce planning.
新冠疫情给医疗系统、教育以及个体从业者,尤其是新获得资格的一线护士和护理人员带来了前所未有的压力。虽然我们知道人们的幸福感受到了负面影响,但缺乏对工作场所经历以及这些经历如何影响幸福感和塑造职业决策的定性探索。鉴于当前医疗劳动力危机以及需要基于证据的教育改革以更好地支持职场学习者,这是文献中的一个关键空白。本研究探讨了护士和护理人员在疫情期间的经历以及这些经历如何影响幸福感和职业决策。
我们采用解释主义的定性方法,对七名新获得资格的护士和两名高级护理人员进行了半结构化访谈。我们运用反思性主题分析来探索和分析数据,考虑在新冠疫情期间开始工作的影响。
我们的研究结果表明疫情对幸福感和职业决策有重大影响。关键问题包括向实践的动荡过渡,这受到临床压力增加(包括高患者数量和劳动力短缺)以及组织和人际层面支持减少的影响。参与者描述了职业价值观的转变,更加重视幸福感作为工作决策的一个决定因素。许多人报告重新评估他们的职业,优先选择能提供更好支持和可管理工作量的岗位或团队,或者考虑完全离开医疗行业。
本研究表明教育政策和实践需要考虑工作场所经历如何影响幸福感和职业决策。除了表明需要进一步研究外,本研究还引发了关于未来劳动力规划的关键讨论。