Mizori Rasi, Ijaz Mueed, Hashem Mohamed, Doyle Ruben, Al Omran Yasser, Musbahi Omar
EFORT Open Rev. 2025 Jun 30;10(7):562-569. doi: 10.1530/EOR-2024-0147.
This scoping review examines the epidemiology and incidence of complications associated with incorrect screw length in orthopaedic trauma surgeries, aiming to underscore its impact on clinical outcomes and healthcare costs.
Guided by Arksey and O'Malley's framework and PRISMA guidelines, a thorough search was conducted across PubMed, Web of Science, Cochrane, and Google Scholar up to April 2024. Studies included must be human-based orthopaedic procedures involving screw length, published in peer-reviewed journals with full text available, and report complications from incorrect screw length; studies excluded were systematic reviews/meta-analyses. Paper characteristics and data on incident rates of complications due to screw protrusion were extracted and presented in a supplementary table using Microsoft Excel.
Of 2,285 studies identified, 31 met the inclusion criteria. Incorrect screw length led to severe complications, including neurovascular damage (7 studies), avascular necrosis (4 studies), delayed union or pseudoarthrosis (9), tendinitis/tendon rupture (12 studies), and pain (10 studies). Notably, improperly sized screws increased neurovascular and avascular necrosis complications, especially in weight-bearing joints. In addition, incorrect screw length was linked to higher hardware removal rates, contributing to increased healthcare costs. Limitations include the inability of some studies to definitively attribute complications to screw protrusion and the exclusion of cases involving joint collapse or solely mechanical complications.
This review underscores the importance of precise screw length selection to prevent complications and improve surgical outcomes. It calls for further research on the medico-legal and economic impacts of screw length errors and the need for better surgical practices.
本范围综述探讨了骨科创伤手术中与螺钉长度不正确相关的并发症的流行病学和发生率,旨在强调其对临床结果和医疗成本的影响。
在阿克斯西和奥马利的框架以及PRISMA指南的指导下,截至2024年4月,对PubMed、科学网、考科蓝和谷歌学术进行了全面检索。纳入的研究必须是涉及螺钉长度的以人为对象的骨科手术,发表在同行评审期刊上且有全文可供获取,并报告因螺钉长度不正确导致的并发症;排除的研究是系统评价/荟萃分析。提取论文特征以及因螺钉突出导致并发症的发生率数据,并使用Microsoft Excel在补充表中呈现。
在识别出的2285项研究中,31项符合纳入标准。螺钉长度不正确会导致严重并发症,包括神经血管损伤(7项研究)、缺血性坏死(4项研究)、骨不连或假关节形成(9项)、肌腱炎/肌腱断裂(12项研究)以及疼痛(10项研究)。值得注意的是,尺寸不当的螺钉会增加神经血管和缺血性坏死并发症,尤其是在负重关节中。此外,螺钉长度不正确与更高的内固定取出率相关,导致医疗成本增加。局限性包括一些研究无法明确将并发症归因于螺钉突出,以及排除了涉及关节塌陷或仅机械性并发症的病例。
本综述强调了精确选择螺钉长度以预防并发症和改善手术结果的重要性。它呼吁进一步研究螺钉长度错误的法医学和经济影响以及更好的手术操作的必要性。