Zhou Yuxun, Long Ren, Liu Xiaoyun
School of Public Health, Peking University, Beijing, China.
Front Public Health. 2025 Jun 18;13:1527676. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1527676. eCollection 2025.
This study aims to analyze how wage structure and individual ability affect practitioners' participation in primary healthcare.
This study employs a mixed moral hazard and adverse selection model to analyze the optimal performance-based wage for general practitioners under separating and pooling equilibrium. Subsequently, we utilize tripartite evolutionary games to analyze the dynamic process of participation strategies to the primary health care with high-and less experienced practitioners.
Our study yields four main findings: (1) Under an effective separating equilibrium, high-quality practitioners receive information rent, and there is no distortion at the top, while less experienced practitioners face allocation distortion. (2) When the performance risk of less experienced practitioners is greater than or equal to that of high-quality practitioners, reducing the performance risk of less experienced practitioners is an effective method of increasing their performance wage. Conversely, when the performance risk of less experienced practitioners is less than that of high-quality practitioners, and they can transform into high-quality practitioners by increasing education costs, they will be incentivized to continue as general practitioners, provided there is a precise promotion mechanism. (3) If reforms are made to the wage structure in primary healthcare, an effective approach is to increase the proportion of the floating part. This would lead primary healthcare institutions to choose contracts under separating equilibrium, encouraging high-quality practitioners to participate in primary healthcare and less experienced practitioners to improve their abilities by increasing education costs. However, the proportion of the floating part in the wage structure should not be excessively large. (4) The effective cost of medical resource utilization influences the wage structure, and establishing reasonable upper and lower limits for performance wages can effectively increase the incentive for high-quality practitioners to participate in primary healthcare.
For the first time, our study employs a tripartite evolutionary game model to analyze the development of the general practitioner system. We analyze how the reform of the wage structure can encourage more practitioners to participate in primary healthcare. Our findings can lay the theoretical foundation for subsequent empirical analyses. Moreover, our findings provide theoretical assistance for government decisions and healthcare institutions.
本研究旨在分析工资结构和个人能力如何影响从业者参与基层医疗服务。
本研究采用混合道德风险和逆向选择模型,分析在分离均衡和混同均衡下全科医生基于绩效的最优工资。随后,我们利用三方演化博弈来分析经验丰富和经验不足的从业者参与基层医疗服务策略的动态过程。
我们的研究得出四个主要结果:(1)在有效的分离均衡下,高素质从业者获得信息租金,不存在“顶部无扭曲”情况,而经验不足的从业者面临配置扭曲。(2)当经验不足的从业者的绩效风险大于或等于高素质从业者的绩效风险时,降低经验不足的从业者的绩效风险是提高其绩效工资的有效方法。相反,当经验不足的从业者的绩效风险小于高素质从业者的绩效风险,且他们可以通过增加教育成本转变为高素质从业者时,若有精确的晋升机制,他们将受到激励继续担任全科医生。(3)如果对基层医疗服务的工资结构进行改革,一种有效的方法是提高浮动部分的比例。这将使基层医疗机构在分离均衡下选择合同,鼓励高素质从业者参与基层医疗服务,促使经验不足的从业者通过增加教育成本来提高自身能力。然而,工资结构中浮动部分的比例不应过大。(4)医疗资源利用的有效成本影响工资结构,为绩效工资设定合理的上限和下限可以有效提高高素质从业者参与基层医疗服务的积极性。
我们的研究首次采用三方演化博弈模型来分析全科医生制度的发展。我们分析了工资结构改革如何鼓励更多从业者参与基层医疗服务。我们的研究结果可为后续的实证分析奠定理论基础。此外,我们的研究结果为政府决策和医疗机构提供了理论支持。