The persistent defect on exercise thallium imaging and its fate after myocardial revascularization: does it represent scar or ischemia?

Persistent defects on serial thallium scans are commonly thought to represent fibrosis or scar. However, such a pattern may also represent severe ischemia. To better understand persistent defects, exercise thallium and resting gated blood pool scans were reviewed in 52 patients pre and post coronary angioplasty for single-vessel left anterior descending (LAD) coronary artery disease, and the fate of persistent defects after successful revascularization was determined. Persistent and transient defects were defined from the average scores of three observers. Ten patients with 16 myocardial segments with persistent defects were compared to another 11 patients with 20 myocardial segments with transient defects. After angioplasty (PTCA), 75% of the regions that had persistent defects and 85% of the regions that had transient defects were normal by visual assessment. In the persistent defect group, only regional wall motion on the resting gated blood pool scan pre PTCA helped to distinguish those segments that would or would not revert to normal. We conclude that regions of persistent defect on thallium scan often revert to normal after PTCA (75%), suggesting that persistent defects may represent hypoperfusion of viable myocardium, and should not preclude consideration of an intervention.