Ramsamooj Anya, Ibrahim Steven M, Gerriets Valerie A, Cusick John K, Ramsamooj Rajendra
Pediatrics, California Northstate University College of Medicine, Elk Grove, USA.
Anesthesiology, California Northstate University College of Medicine, Elk Grove, USA.
Cureus. 2025 Jun 2;17(6):e85262. doi: 10.7759/cureus.85262. eCollection 2025 Jun.
As technology advances in every aspect of our lives, educational curricula are moving away from traditional didactic lectures toward more interactive modalities. While there are many ways to incorporate non-traditional learning methods into medical curricula, the increasing prevalence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) offers a novel avenue. This study aims to determine whether the use of AI enhances learning as compared to more traditional flipped classroom styles, such as lecture slides and voice-over videos.
Incoming first-year medical students were given learning materials prior to course instruction. Participating students were randomly assigned to three educational groups: PowerPoint slides only (PPT), voice-over videos and PowerPoint slides (VO+PPT), or Artificial Intelligence learning and PowerPoint slides (AI+PPT). After reviewing the materials, all study participants took a 22-question formative quiz. The average overall scores and the scores on the five most "difficult" questions were assessed between groups.
Sixty-two incoming students participated in this study. There was no significant change between groups regarding overall scores. The PPT group had significantly lower scores on the five most "difficult" questions when compared to the VO+PPT (p = 0.026) and AI+PPT (p = 0.004) groups. However, there were no significant changes in scores on the five most "difficult" questions between the VO+PPT and AI+PPT groups (p = 0.834).
The VO+PPT and AI+PPT groups performed similarly but significantly better than the PPT-only group regarding performance on "difficult" questions. Overall, our study provides evidence that Artificial Intelligence and voice-over modalities are equally viable methods of learning, depending on the demands of professors and students.
随着科技在我们生活的各个方面不断进步,教育课程正从传统的讲授式讲座转向更具互动性的模式。虽然有许多方法可以将非传统学习方法融入医学课程,但人工智能(AI)的日益普及提供了一条新途径。本研究旨在确定与更传统的翻转课堂风格(如讲座幻灯片和旁白视频)相比,使用人工智能是否能提高学习效果。
在课程教学之前,给即将入学的一年级医学生提供学习材料。参与的学生被随机分配到三个教育组:仅使用PowerPoint幻灯片(PPT)、旁白视频和PowerPoint幻灯片(VO + PPT),或人工智能学习和PowerPoint幻灯片(AI + PPT)。在复习材料后,所有研究参与者进行了一次包含22个问题的形成性测验。评估了各组之间的平均总分以及五个最“难”问题的得分。
62名即将入学的学生参与了本研究。各组之间的总分没有显著变化。与VO + PPT组(p = 0.026)和AI + PPT组(p = 0.004)相比,PPT组在五个最“难”问题上的得分显著更低。然而,VO + PPT组和AI + PPT组在五个最“难”问题上的得分没有显著变化(p = 0.834)。
VO + PPT组和AI + PPT组的表现相似,但在“难”问题上的表现明显优于仅使用PPT的组。总体而言,我们的研究提供了证据表明,根据教授和学生的需求,人工智能和旁白模式是同样可行的学习方法。