通过教育提高大量出血方案的依从性与患者生存率相关。
Improving the Compliance of Massive Hemorrhage Protocols Through Education Is Associated with Patient Survival.
作者信息
Paniagua-Iglesias Pilar, Rincón-Ferrari Maria Dolores, Candela-Toha Angel, Marcos-Jubilar Maria, Barquero-Lopez Marta, Gich-Saladich Ignasi, Medina-Marrero Laura, Bosch-Llobet Alba, Garrido-Fleischmann Daniela, Ordoñez-Llanos Jordi, Urrutia-Cuchí Gerard
机构信息
Anaesthesiology Department, University Hospital Santa Creu i Sant Pau, 08041 Barcelona, Spain.
Institut d'Investigació Biomèdica Sant Pau (IIB SANT PAU), 08041 Barcelona, Spain.
出版信息
J Clin Med. 2025 Jun 30;14(13):4632. doi: 10.3390/jcm14134632.
In 2015, Spanish scientific societies published a consensus document on managing massive hemorrhage (MH). This study aimed to evaluate the knowledge and application of the Massive Hemorrhage Protocol (MHP) among healthcare professionals and to assess whether an educational intervention could improve compliance and patient outcomes. A two-phase observational study was conducted in four Spanish university hospitals. In phase one, compliance with MHP recommendations was surveyed. Based on the findings, educational sessions were implemented, focusing on the least known or followed recommendations. Compliance was then reassessed. Primary outcome was adherence to MHP; secondary outcomes included morbidity and 24 h and in-hospital mortality. The MHP was activated in 303 MH episodes, mostly of surgical (42.6%) or traumatic (25%) origin. The most followed recommendation before the intervention was protocol activation (94%), which improved to 98.3% post-intervention ( = 0.049). Lesser-followed recommendations such as requesting a hemorrhage lab panel and correcting hypothermia improved after intervention from 39% to 50.4% ( = 0.05) and 31.3% to 43.8% ( = 0.027), respectively. Overall compliance increased from 68% to 73% ( = 0.05). Mortality remained high in both phases, 24 h (25.4%) and in-hospital (42.2%). Patients who required massive transfusion had higher mortality (53.6%) than those who did not (35.9%, = 0.03). Survivors had higher protocol compliance ( = 0.003 at 24 h; = 0.049 in-hospital). Educational intervention modestly improved adherence to MHP recommendations. Higher compliance was associated with better survival outcomes, supporting the need for targeted educational strategies to enhance protocol implementation and improve care in MH cases.
2015年,西班牙各科学学会发表了一份关于大量出血(MH)管理的共识文件。本研究旨在评估医疗保健专业人员对大量出血协议(MHP)的了解和应用情况,并评估教育干预是否能提高依从性和改善患者预后。在西班牙的四家大学医院进行了一项两阶段观察性研究。在第一阶段,调查了对MHP建议的依从情况。根据调查结果,开展了教育课程,重点关注那些最不为人所知或遵循最少的建议。然后重新评估依从情况。主要结局是对MHP的依从性;次要结局包括发病率、24小时死亡率和住院死亡率。在303例MH发作中启动了MHP,其中大多数起源于手术(42.6%)或创伤(25%)。干预前遵循最多的建议是协议启动(94%),干预后提高到98.3%(P = 0.049)。其他较少遵循的建议,如要求进行出血实验室检查和纠正体温过低,干预后分别从39%提高到50.4%(P = 0.05)和从31.3%提高到43.8%(P = 0.027)。总体依从性从68%提高到73%(P = 0.05)。两个阶段的死亡率都很高,24小时死亡率为25.4%,住院死亡率为42.2%。需要大量输血的患者死亡率(53.6%)高于不需要的患者(35.9%,P = 0.03)。幸存者的协议依从性更高(24小时时P = 0.003;住院时P = 0.049)。教育干预适度提高了对MHP建议的依从性。更高的依从性与更好的生存结局相关,这支持了需要有针对性的教育策略来加强协议实施并改善MH病例的护理。
相似文献
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022-5-20
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2018-2-6
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016-10-6
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2015-6-12
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022-10-4
本文引用的文献
Med Intensiva (Engl Ed). 2023-8
Med Clin (Barc). 2023-10-13
Am Surg. 2023-5
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021-1-1
Emerg Med J. 2020-2