Wang Aoxiang, Zhu Ya-Nan, Setianegara Jufri, Lin Yuting, Xiao Peng, Xie Qingguo, Gao Hao
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China.
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Kansas Medical Center, Kansas, USA.
Med Phys. 2025 Jul;52(7):e17941. doi: 10.1002/mp.17941.
Intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT) using pencil beam technique scans tumor in a layer by layer, then spot by spot manner. It can provide highly conformal dose to tumor targets and spare nearby organs-at-risk (OAR). Fast delivery of IMPT can improve patient comfort and reduce motion-induced uncertainties. Since energy layer switching time dominants the plan delivery time, reducing the number of energy layers is important for improving delivery efficiency. Although various energy layer optimization (ELO) methods exist, they are rarely experimentally validated or clinically implemented, since it is technically challenging to integrate these methods into commercially available treatment planning system (TPS) that is not open-source.
This work develops and experimentally validates an in-house TPS (IH-TPS) that incorporates a novel ELO method for the purpose of fast IMPT.
The dose calculation accuracy of IH-TPS is verified against the measured beam data and the RayStation TPS. For treatment planning, a novel ELO method via greed selection algorithm is proposed to reduce energy layer switching time and total plan delivery time. To validate the planning accuracy of IH-TPS, the 3D gamma index is calculated between IH-TPS plans and RayStation plans for various scenarios. Patient-specific quality-assurance (QA) verifications are conducted to experimentally verify the delivered dose from the IH-TPS plans for several clinical cases.
Dose distributions in IH-TPS matched with those from RayStation TPS, with 3D gamma index results exceeding 95% (2 mm, 2%). The ELO method significantly reduced the delivery time while maintaining plan quality. For instance, in a brain case, the number of energy layers was reduced from 78 to 40 (reduction of 38 layers), leading to a 62% reduction in total delivery time. Patient-specific QA validation with the IBA ProteusONE proton machine confirmed a > 95% pass rate for all cases.
An IH-TPS equipped with a novel ELO algorithm is developed and experimentally validated for the purpose of fast IMPT, with enhanced delivery efficiency and preserved plan quality.
采用笔形束技术的调强质子治疗(IMPT)以逐层、逐点的方式扫描肿瘤。它能够为肿瘤靶区提供高度适形的剂量,并保护附近的危及器官(OAR)。快速的IMPT治疗可以提高患者的舒适度并减少运动引起的不确定性。由于能量层切换时间占计划交付时间的主导,减少能量层的数量对于提高交付效率很重要。尽管存在各种能量层优化(ELO)方法,但它们很少经过实验验证或临床应用,因为将这些方法集成到非开源的商用治疗计划系统(TPS)中在技术上具有挑战性。
本研究开发并通过实验验证了一种内部TPS(IH-TPS),该系统采用了一种新颖的ELO方法以实现快速IMPT。
将IH-TPS的剂量计算准确性与测量的射束数据和RayStation TPS进行对比验证。对于治疗计划,提出了一种通过贪婪选择算法的新颖ELO方法,以减少能量层切换时间和总计划交付时间。为了验证IH-TPS的计划准确性,针对各种情况计算了IH-TPS计划与RayStation计划之间的三维伽马指数。针对几个临床病例进行了患者特异性质量保证(QA)验证,以实验验证IH-TPS计划所交付的剂量。
IH-TPS中的剂量分布与RayStation TPS的剂量分布相匹配,三维伽马指数结果超过95%(2毫米,2%)。ELO方法在保持计划质量的同时显著减少了交付时间。例如,在一个脑部病例中,能量层的数量从78层减少到40层(减少了38层),导致总交付时间减少了62%。使用IBA ProteusONE质子机进行的患者特异性QA验证证实所有病例的通过率均大于95%。
开发并通过实验验证了一种配备新颖ELO算法的IH-TPS,以实现快速IMPT,提高了交付效率并保持了计划质量。