Alnsour Marwa M, Alenezi Razan, Barakat Motaz, Al-Omiri Mahmoud K
Department of Restorative Dentistry, University of Jordan, Amman, Jordan.
Dental Department, Jordan University Hospital, Amman, Jordan.
BMC Oral Health. 2025 Jul 19;25(1):1207. doi: 10.1186/s12903-025-06377-5.
With the growing use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in healthcare, language models like ChatGPT are increasingly being used to provide health information. Given smoking's significant impact on oral health, including periodontal disease, tooth loss, oral cancer, and impaired healing-this study assesses ChatGPT's effectiveness in answering inquiries about the effects of smoking on oral health.
A total of 119 smoking-related dental health questions were generated using online tools and categorized into five domains: periodontal conditions, teeth and health, oral hygiene and breath, oral soft tissues, and oral surgery. ChatGPT 3.5 responses were evaluated for usefulness, readability (FKG index and, SMOG index), quality (Global Quality Scale), reliability (CLEAR tool), and understandability/actionability (PEMAT). Statistical analyses included ANOVA, Kruskal-Wallis, Mann-Whitney U, and Spearman correlation tests using SPSS v20.
ChatGPT responses were rated as "very useful" (36.1%) or "useful" (42.0%) for most questions. The oral hygiene and breath category received the highest usefulness scores (p =.002). Readability scores indicated that 35.3% of responses were very difficult to read. Surgery-related questions were significantly harder to read (p <.001). The overall quality and reliability of responses was moderate to good. Although understandability was generally high, actionability was limited, with only 23.5% of responses achieving high actionability (> 70%).
ChatGPT provides reliable, high-quality information on smoking's impact on oral health, suitable for general health education. However, it lacks actionable, personalized guidance, limiting its effectiveness in supporting behavioral change and health management.
随着人工智能(AI)在医疗保健领域的应用日益广泛,像ChatGPT这样的语言模型越来越多地被用于提供健康信息。鉴于吸烟对口腔健康有重大影响,包括牙周疾病、牙齿脱落、口腔癌和愈合受损,本研究评估了ChatGPT在回答有关吸烟对口腔健康影响的询问方面的有效性。
使用在线工具生成了总共119个与吸烟相关的牙齿健康问题,并将其分为五个领域:牙周状况、牙齿与健康、口腔卫生与口气、口腔软组织和口腔外科。对ChatGPT 3.5的回答进行了有用性、可读性(FKG指数和SMOG指数)、质量(全球质量量表)、可靠性(CLEAR工具)以及可理解性/可操作性(PEMAT)评估。统计分析包括使用SPSS v20进行的方差分析、Kruskal-Wallis检验、Mann-Whitney U检验和Spearman相关性检验。
对于大多数问题,ChatGPT的回答被评为“非常有用”(36.1%)或“有用”(42.0%)。口腔卫生与口气类别获得了最高的有用性得分(p = 0.002)。可读性得分表明,35.3%的回答非常难读。与手术相关的问题明显更难读(p < 0.001)。回答的整体质量和可靠性为中等至良好。虽然可理解性一般较高,但可操作性有限,只有23.5%的回答具有高可操作性(> 70%)。
ChatGPT提供了关于吸烟对口腔健康影响的可靠、高质量信息,适用于一般健康教育。然而,它缺乏可操作的个性化指导,限制了其在支持行为改变和健康管理方面的有效性。