Cao Bing, Zhang Haochen, Zhang Nan
Beijing Key Laboratory of Green Built Environment and Energy Efficient Technology, Beijing University of Technology, Pingleyuan100, Chaoyang District, Beijing, 100124, China.
Infect Dis Model. 2025 Jul 5;10(4):1238-1251. doi: 10.1016/j.idm.2025.07.004. eCollection 2025 Dec.
The risk of transmission of respiratory infectious diseases in emergency rooms is high, posing a severe threat to the health of healthcare workers (HCWs).
The study was conducted in an emergency room of a medical school at a university in Hong Kong during a clinical skills competition. A total of 19,246 s of video surveillance data were collected, recording the treatment of three types of patients (P1: infusion patient, P2: critically ill patient, P3: agitated patient). Taking coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) as an example, a multi-route transmission model was established to assess the infection risk for HCWs and the effectiveness of various interventions.
The average distances between HCWs and patients during the treatment of P1, P2, and P3 were 0.8 (25-75 percentile: 0.6, 1.1) m, 1.0 (0.8, 1.2) m, and 0.5 (0.4, 0.7) m, respectively. When treating P2, due to intubation procedures, the hourly risk of infection was highest at 43.4 % if no HCWs wore masks, which was 5.1 and 3.1 times higher than it during treatment of P1 (8.5 %) and P3 (13.9 %), respectively. During the treatment, without mask protection, the average hourly infection risk for nurses was 11.0 % (P1), 41.2 % (P2), and 16.8 % (P3), which was 1.8 times (P1), 0.9 times (P2), and 1.5 times (P3) that of doctors. If HCWs wear N95 respirators and surgical masks throughout, the total infection risk can be reduced by 94.7 % and 53.9 %, respectively. Increasing the ventilation rate from 1 ACH to 6 ACH reduced the infection risk through long-range airborne transmission by 43.8 % (P1), 36.1 % (P2), and 31.6 % (P3), with a total infection risk reduction of 2.4 % (P1), 5.6 % (P2), and 1.6 % (P3), respectively.
The findings of the study provide a scientific support for the precise prevention and control of respiratory infectious diseases under different treatments in emergency rooms.
急诊室呼吸道传染病传播风险高,对医护人员健康构成严重威胁。
该研究在香港一所大学医学院的急诊室进行,当时正在举办临床技能竞赛。共收集了19246秒的视频监控数据,记录了三类患者(P1:输液患者、P2:重症患者、P3:躁动患者)的治疗情况。以2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)为例,建立多途径传播模型,评估医护人员的感染风险及各种干预措施的效果。
治疗P1、P2和P3患者时,医护人员与患者之间的平均距离分别为0.8(25-75百分位数:0.6,1.1)米、1.0(0.8,1.2)米和0.5(0.4,0.7)米。治疗P2患者时,由于插管操作,如果没有医护人员戴口罩,每小时感染风险最高可达43.4%,分别是治疗P1患者(8.5%)和P3患者(13.9%)时的5.1倍和3.1倍。治疗过程中,在没有口罩防护的情况下,护士每小时的平均感染风险为11.0%(P1)、41.2%(P2)和16.8%(P3),分别是医生的1.8倍(P1)、0.9倍(P2)和1.5倍(P3)。如果医护人员全程佩戴N95口罩和外科口罩,总感染风险可分别降低94.7%和53.9%。将通风率从每小时1次换气(ACH)提高到6次换气,通过远距离空气传播降低的感染风险分别为43.8%(P1)、36.1%(P2)和31.6%(P3),总感染风险分别降低2.4%(P1)、5.6%(P2)和1.6%(P3)。
该研究结果为急诊室不同治疗情况下呼吸道传染病的精准防控提供了科学依据。