Ren Xiaomei, Yan Ling, Yu Bing, Dai Qin
Department of Disinfection Supply Room, The Southwest Hospital, Army Medical University, Chong qing, 400038, China.
Department of Paediatrics, The Southwest Hospital, Army Medical University, Chong qing, 400038, China.
BMC Psychol. 2025 Jul 21;13(1):809. doi: 10.1186/s40359-025-03128-7.
Public crisis has a profound impact on mental health, particularly among young children, since that they are often encountered with disrupted routine, restricted movement, school closure, caregiver illness or distress, greater likelihood of aversive or neglecting parenting etc. However, the mental distress of young children aged below 12 years-old has been less attended. Based on the Risk Factor Model, this study aims to observe the levels and predictors of posttraumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) in children aged 3-12 years at the hardest-hit area of China during the early stage of the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) outbreak.
Chinese children who aged 3-12 years at Hubei province (the hardest-hit area, n = 1444) and other areas (n = 262) were surveyed through an online questionnaire from February 24 to March 21, 2020, with hyper-arousal and avoidance sub-scales of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Check list-Civilian Version. For children who could not read Chinese or could not fully understand the questions (mainly third grade in primary school or lower grade), parents were encouraged to assist to fill in the answers based on their observations, explanation and inquiry.
The rate of avoidance and hyper-arousal symptoms among the surveyed children was 5.51% and 6.10% respectively. Chi-square tests showed that children from the hardest-hit area and other areas reported equivalent levels of avoidance (5.75% V.S. 4.20%, 858.98 V.S. 823.27, p > 0.05) and hyper-arousal symptoms (5.89% V.S. 7.25%, 847.41 V.S. 887.06, p > 0.05). Children reported less avoidance and hyper-arousal symptoms, in sub-population who aged 3-6 years-old, not experiencing negative life-events, not perceiving negative emotions, with unchanged caring from parents, while centralized isolation group reported the highest scores on the hyper-arousal symptom. Hierarchical linear regression analysis revealed that older age, having been quarantined at home, having perceived negative emotions, and having experienced negative life-events, were predictors of both avoidance and hyper-arousal symptoms, while death of family member due to infection, and unchanged or more help from parents were negative predictors of avoidance symptom, and unchanged help and gentleness, more gentleness and respecting from parents were protective predictors of hyper-arousal symptom. Notably, having heard horrible news about the pandemic was the strongest prediction for both symptoms.
The results are among the first to reveal the levels of PTSS in young children aged 3-12 years under crisis. The rate of avoidant and hyper-arousal symptoms in children is 5.51% and 6.10% respectively, which is equivalent in children at hardest-hit and other area, and lower than that of pre-COVID disasters such as earthquakes (13.1%), but higher than those reported in college students during COVID-19 (2.7%). Due to omission of intrusion-symptom observation, the findings may indicate partial symptoms and result in lower PTSS rate. Risk and protective predictors of PTSS help to recognize high-risk sub-populations and prevent PTSS in young children under crisis.
公共危机对心理健康有深远影响,尤其是对幼儿,因为他们经常面临日常生活被打乱、行动受限、学校关闭、照顾者生病或苦恼、遭受厌恶或忽视性养育的可能性增加等情况。然而,12岁以下幼儿的心理困扰较少受到关注。基于风险因素模型,本研究旨在观察2019年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)疫情早期中国受灾最严重地区3至12岁儿童创伤后应激症状(PTSS)的水平及预测因素。
2020年2月24日至3月21日,通过在线问卷对湖北省(受灾最严重地区,n = 1444)和其他地区(n = 2,62)的3至12岁中国儿童进行了调查,使用创伤后应激障碍检查表-平民版的高唤醒和回避子量表。对于不识字或不能完全理解问题的儿童(主要是小学三年级及以下),鼓励家长根据他们的观察、解释和询问协助填写答案。
被调查儿童中回避症状和高唤醒症状的发生率分别为5.51%和6.10%。卡方检验显示,受灾最严重地区和其他地区的儿童报告的回避症状水平相当(5.75%对4.20%,858.98对823.27,p > 0.05),高唤醒症状水平也相当(5.89%对7.25%,847.41对887.06,p > 0.05)。在3至6岁、未经历负面生活事件、未感知负面情绪、父母关爱未变的亚组儿童中,报告的回避和高唤醒症状较少,而集中隔离组在高唤醒症状上得分最高。分层线性回归分析显示,年龄较大、曾居家隔离、感知到负面情绪以及经历过负面生活事件是回避和高唤醒症状的预测因素,而家庭成员因感染死亡以及父母帮助未变或更多是回避症状的负向预测因素,父母帮助未变且温和、更多温和与尊重是高唤醒症状的保护性预测因素。值得注意的是,听说过关于疫情的可怕消息是这两种症状最强的预测因素。
这些结果首次揭示了危机情况下3至12岁幼儿的PTSS水平。儿童中回避和高唤醒症状的发生率分别为5.51%和6.10%,在受灾最严重地区和其他地区的儿童中相当,低于COVID-19之前的地震等灾害(13.1%),但高于COVID-19期间大学生报告的发生率(2.7%)。由于遗漏了侵入性症状观察,这些发现可能仅表明部分症状,导致PTSS发生率较低。PTSS的风险和保护性预测因素有助于识别高危亚组并预防危机情况下幼儿的PTSS。