Dong Yuhang, Shi Zhengfeng, Yao Junsheng, Zhang Li, Chen Yongkang, Jia Junyan
School of Mechanical, Electrical & Information Engineering, Shangdong University, Weihai 264209, China.
Shangdong Key Laboratory of Intelligent Electronic Packaging Test and Application, Shangdong University, Weihai 264209, China.
Sensors (Basel). 2025 Jul 14;25(14):4388. doi: 10.3390/s25144388.
The Zhurong rover of the Tianwen-1 mission has detected sulfates in its landing area. The analysis of these sulfates provides scientific evidence for exploring past hydration conditions and atmospheric evolution on Mars. As a non-contact technique with long-range detection capability, Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) is widely used for elemental identification on Mars. However, quantitative analysis of anionic elements using LIBS remains challenging due to the weak characteristic spectral lines of evaporite salt elements, such as sulfur, in LIBS spectra, which provide limited quantitative information. This study proposes a quantitative analysis method for sulfur in sulfate-containing Martian analogs by leveraging spectral line correlations, full-spectrum information, and prior knowledge, aiming to address the challenges of sulfur identification and quantification in Martian exploration. To enhance the accuracy of sulfur quantification, two analytical models for high and low sulfur concentrations were developed. Samples were classified using infrared spectroscopy based on sulfur content levels. Subsequently, multimodal deep learning models were developed for quantitative analysis by integrating LIBS and infrared spectra, based on varying concentrations. Compared to traditional unimodal models, the multimodal method simultaneously utilizes elemental chemical information from LIBS spectra and molecular structural and vibrational characteristics from infrared spectroscopy. Considering that sulfur exhibits distinct absorption bands in infrared spectra but demonstrates weak characteristic lines in LIBS spectra due to its low ionization energy, the combination of both spectral techniques enables the model to capture complementary sample features, thereby effectively improving prediction accuracy and robustness. To validate the advantages of the multimodal approach, comparative analyses were conducted against unimodal methods. Furthermore, to optimize model performance, different feature selection algorithms were evaluated. Ultimately, an XGBoost-based feature selection method incorporating prior knowledge was employed to identify optimal LIBS spectral features, and the selected feature subsets were utilized in multimodal modeling to enhance stability. Experimental results demonstrate that, compared to the BPNN, SVR, and Inception unimodal methods, the proposed multimodal approach achieves at least a 92.36% reduction in RMSE and a 46.3% improvement in R.
天问一号任务的祝融号火星车在其着陆区探测到了硫酸盐。对这些硫酸盐的分析为探索火星过去的水合条件和大气演化提供了科学依据。激光诱导击穿光谱技术(LIBS)作为一种具有远程探测能力的非接触技术,在火星元素识别中得到了广泛应用。然而,由于LIBS光谱中蒸发盐元素(如硫)的特征谱线较弱,提供的定量信息有限,利用LIBS对阴离子元素进行定量分析仍然具有挑战性。本研究提出了一种利用光谱线相关性、全谱信息和先验知识对含硫酸盐火星模拟物中的硫进行定量分析的方法,旨在解决火星探测中硫识别和定量的挑战。为提高硫定量的准确性,开发了高硫浓度和低硫浓度的两种分析模型。基于硫含量水平,使用红外光谱对样品进行分类。随后,基于不同浓度,通过整合LIBS光谱和红外光谱,开发了多模态深度学习模型用于定量分析。与传统的单模态模型相比,多模态方法同时利用了LIBS光谱中的元素化学信息和红外光谱中的分子结构及振动特征。考虑到硫在红外光谱中表现出明显的吸收带,但由于其电离能较低,在LIBS光谱中特征线较弱,两种光谱技术的结合使模型能够捕捉互补的样品特征,从而有效提高预测准确性和鲁棒性。为验证多模态方法的优势,与单模态方法进行了对比分析。此外,为优化模型性能,评估了不同的特征选择算法。最终,采用了一种结合先验知识的基于XGBoost的特征选择方法来识别最佳的LIBS光谱特征,并将所选特征子集用于多模态建模以提高稳定性。实验结果表明,与BPNN、SVR和Inception单模态方法相比,所提出的多模态方法的均方根误差(RMSE)至少降低了92.3%,相关系数(R)提高了约46.3%。