Hudson Samuel, Tooby James, Roe Gregory, Sawczuk Thomas, Cazzola Dario, Cross Matt, Jones Ben, Kemp Simon, Whitehead Sarah, Stokes Keith
Centre for Health and Injury and Illness Prevention in Sport, University of Bath, Bath, UK.
UK Collaborating Centre on Injury and Illness Prevention in Sport (UKCCIIS), University of Bath, Bath, UK.
Sports Med. 2025 Aug 2. doi: 10.1007/s40279-025-02287-2.
The aim of this study was to describe the incidence and magnitude of head acceleration events (HAEs) during elite men's and women's rugby union training for different contact training levels and drill types.
Data were collected during the 2022-23 and 2023-24 seasons from 203 men and 125 women from 13 clubs using instrumented mouthguards (iMGs) during in-season training. One author reviewed the training videos to identify the contact level and drill type. HAE incidence was calculated per player minute.
For men's forwards and backs, only 4.7% and 5.8% of HAEs were ≥ 25 g and ≥ 1.5 Krad/s, and 3.4% and 4.4% for women's forwards and backs, respectively. The incidence of ≥ 5 g and ≥ 0.4 Krad/s was highest during full-contact training for men's forwards (0.20/min) and backs (0.16/min) and women's forwards (0.10/min). HAE incidence was 2-3 times higher during repetition-based compared with game-based training drills for men's forwards (0.25/min vs 0.09/min) and backs (0.22/min vs 0.09/min) and women's forwards (0.09/min vs 0.04/min) and backs (0.08/min vs 0.03/min). HAE incidences were halved when repetition-based training drills used pads compared with no pads for men's forwards (0.21/min vs 0.44/min) and backs (0.17/min vs 0.30/min), and women's forwards (0.06/min vs 0.14/min) and backs (0.06/min vs 0.10/min).
The average HAE incidence (~ 13-20% of weekly HAEs) and magnitude during an in-season training week is very low compared with matches. Opportunities to materially reduce HAE exposure in training are likely more limited than previously assumed. Future research on HAE load and injury, and understanding players' specific weekly training exposure, may inform effective individual player management.
本研究旨在描述精英男子和女子橄榄球联盟在不同接触性训练水平和训练类型的赛季训练期间头部加速事件(HAEs)的发生率和严重程度。
在2022 - 23赛季和2023 - 24赛季期间,使用仪器化护齿(iMGs)从13个俱乐部的203名男性和125名女性运动员在赛季内训练时收集数据。由一名作者查看训练视频以确定接触水平和训练类型。HAE发生率按运动员每分钟计算。
对于男子前锋和后卫,分别只有4.7%和5.8%的HAEs≥25g且≥1.5Krad/s,女子前锋和后卫分别为3.4%和4.4%。≥5g且≥0.4Krad/s的发生率在男子前锋(0.20/分钟)、后卫(0.16/分钟)和女子前锋(0.10/分钟)的全接触训练期间最高。与基于比赛的训练相比,基于重复的训练期间男子前锋(0.25/分钟对0.09/分钟)、后卫(0.22/分钟对0.09/分钟)、女子前锋(0.09/分钟对0.04/分钟)和后卫(0.08/分钟对0.03/分钟)的HAE发生率高出2 - 3倍。当基于重复的训练使用护垫时,男子前锋(0.21/分钟对0.44/分钟)、后卫(0.17/分钟对0.30/分钟)、女子前锋(0.06/分钟对0.14/分钟)和后卫(0.06/分钟对0.10/分钟)的HAE发生率减半。
与比赛相比,赛季内训练周的平均HAE发生率(约占每周HAEs的13 - 20%)和严重程度非常低。在训练中大幅降低HAE暴露的机会可能比之前设想的更有限。未来关于HAE负荷与损伤以及了解运动员具体每周训练暴露情况的研究,可能为有效的个体运动员管理提供依据。