PURPOSE

Patients with stage III clear cell renal cell carcinoma are at high risk for recurrence after nephrectomy. To mitigate overtreatment, there is a pressing clinical need to determine which patients benefit most from perioperative immune checkpoint inhibition. We performed a multimodal digital spatial analysis of gene and protein expression in stage III primary renal cell carcinomas, a subset of which had preoperative immune checkpoint inhibition exposure.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Surgically resected tumors from stage III clear cell renal cell carcinoma patients were analyzed using the Nanostring GeoMx Digital Spatial Profiler. Differential expression analysis was performed and validated using NCT02210117 trial data to identify genes associated with immune checkpoint blockade and clinical response. A gene score was then generated to predict overall survival in patients from The Cancer Genome Atlas.

RESULTS

Among 19 patients, RNA expression significantly differed based on preoperative immune checkpoint blockade and recurrence; CD8+ effector and central-memory T-cell signatures were less prevalent in the treatment-naive with recurrence group. Three out of four patients with preoperative immune checkpoint inhibition had recurrence. External validation yielded a 4-gene set (GZMK, GZMA, ITGAL, and IL7R); higher gene expression levels predicted better overall survival in The Cancer Genome Atlas cohort (p=0.005).

DISCUSSION

Preoperative immune checkpoint blockade favorably altered the tumor microenvironment to resemble that of treatment-naive patients without recurrence. However, this did not translate to better clinical outcomes. On external validation, the genes GZMK, GZMA, ITGAL, and IL7R were modifiable with immune checkpoint inhibition and associated with improved survival. Further investigation to assess if patients with low baseline expression of these genes may particularly benefit from perioperative immune checkpoint blockade is warranted.