Watt Helen M G
The University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Br J Educ Psychol. 2025 Sep;95 Suppl 1(Suppl 1):S212-S219. doi: 10.1111/bjep.70018. Epub 2025 Aug 7.
Traditionally, research in educational psychology had overlooked teachers' motivations and emotions, focusing on students. This has changed markedly in the last 20 years, when recent studies have made rapid strides to study the motivations and emotions of teachers too, as documented in the contributions to this Special Issue. In this concluding article, I discuss four of the included articles focussed on teacher emotions, indicating directions for future research.
The four studies showcase state-of-the-art analyses of teachers' situation-specific state emotions in relation to a range of correlates, incorporating observations and student reports additional to data from teachers across the contexts of Switzerland and Germany, Taiwan, Finland and Austria. They collectively attest to the importance of teachers' emotions in the teaching and learning enterprise. However, some of the studies used small samples or cross-sectional designs, and not all of the findings were consistent.
To inform theory and practice concerning the role of teacher emotions in teaching quality-the goal of this Special Issue-I recommend that we need to build the knowledge base in three key areas. First, which emotions are most influential, for what aspects of teaching quality? Second, by what processes do emotions affect teaching quality (and thereby student outcomes)? Third, how are teacher emotions shaped and how could they be shaped? To this end, it may be helpful for future studies to focus on causal designs, sufficiently powered samples of participants and timepoints, multiple informants, indicators for precise measurement and broadened emic and etic contextual aspects.
传统上,教育心理学研究忽视了教师的动机和情感,主要关注学生。在过去20年里,这种情况有了显著变化,近期研究也迅速展开对教师动机和情感的研究,本特刊的稿件对此有相关记载。在这篇总结性文章中,我将讨论四篇聚焦于教师情感的文章,并指出未来的研究方向。
这四项研究展示了对教师特定情境下的状态情感与一系列相关因素的前沿分析,纳入了观察结果和学生报告,以及来自瑞士、德国、台湾、芬兰和奥地利等地教师的数据。它们共同证明了教师情感在教学活动中的重要性。然而,其中一些研究样本较小或采用横断面设计,而且并非所有研究结果都一致。
为了丰富关于教师情感在教学质量中作用的理论与实践——这也是本特刊的目标——我建议我们需要在三个关键领域建立知识基础。第一,哪些情感对教学质量的哪些方面最具影响力?第二,情感通过哪些过程影响教学质量(进而影响学生成绩)?第三,教师情感是如何形成的,又如何能够被塑造?为此,未来的研究不妨聚焦于因果设计、足够大样本量的参与者和时间点、多个信息提供者、精确测量的指标以及更广泛的主位和客位背景因素。