Ghosal Jyoti, Nanda Anita, Behera Pallavi, Som Meena, Bal Madhusmita, Ranjit Manoranjan, Kanungo Srikanta, Kadam Shridhar Murlidharrao, Pati Sanghamitra, Dutta Ambarish
School of Public Health, KIIT Deemed to be University, Bhubaneswar, Odisha, India.
ICMR-Regional Medical Research Center, Bhubaneswar, Odisha, India.
BMC Public Health. 2025 Aug 11;25(1):2727. doi: 10.1186/s12889-025-23697-x.
A package of Maternal, Newborn and Child Health (MNCH) services are administered sequentially to mother-child dyads as Continuum of Care (CoC), but often each intervention is reviewed in silo in low-middle-income countries like India. Therefore, we aimed to examine the coverage of the entire package by computing composite CoC score of Indian mother-child dyads. We also aimed to estimate the effect of Indian states on CoC after adjusting for variations in socio-economic determinants; and then rank the Indian states based on their adjusted effects.
Women (15-49 years) with most recently-born child (in last 5 years) aged 12-23 months (n = 40,687) from National Family Health Survey-5 (2019-21) of India were analysed. Nineteen CoC interventions (Y/N) were added (equally-weighted) to construct a composite CoC score. Multi-level models were used to study the state effect on CoC score after adjusting for individual-level wealth, education, caste, urban/rural residence and fertility. Indian states were ranked by their CoC performance using adjusted state residuals from the model.
Only 3% dyads received all the 19 interventions, however, 50% received 14/19. Sterile delivery kit usage (94.4%), newborn weighing (92.4%) and skilled birth attendance (89.4%) were services with higher coverage, whereas early initiation of breastfeeding (43.7%) and appropriate iron-folate consumption (56.8%) had low coverage. The state factor explained 23% CoC score. Odisha, a comparatively less-developed state, was ranked first and also other less-developed states like Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh outperformed richer counterparts. But many traditionally weaker Northern and North-Eastern states continued to lag behind.
Odisha and a few other less-developed Indian states demonstrated that good CoC coverage can be achieved even with restricted resources, perhaps through strengthening of public health system. Other states should emulate and help India as a nation achieve full CoC coverage of all its mother-child dyads and attain MNCH-related sustainable development goals.
一整套孕产妇、新生儿和儿童健康(MNCH)服务作为连续护理(CoC)按顺序提供给母婴二元组,但在印度等中低收入国家,往往对每项干预措施进行单独审查。因此,我们旨在通过计算印度母婴二元组的综合CoC得分来检查整套服务的覆盖情况。我们还旨在在调整社会经济决定因素的差异后,估计印度各邦对连续护理的影响;然后根据调整后的影响对印度各邦进行排名。
对来自印度第五次全国家庭健康调查(2019 - 2021年)中年龄在15 - 49岁、最近生育的孩子年龄在12 - 23个月(n = 40,687)的妇女进行分析。添加了19项连续护理干预措施(是/否)(权重相等)以构建综合CoC得分。在调整了个体层面的财富、教育、种姓、城乡居住情况和生育率后,使用多层次模型研究各邦对CoC得分的影响。根据模型中调整后的邦残差,对印度各邦的连续护理表现进行排名。
只有3%的二元组接受了所有19项干预措施,然而,50%的二元组接受了14/19项。无菌分娩包的使用(94.4%)、新生儿称重(92.4%)和熟练接生(89.4%)是覆盖率较高的服务,而早期开始母乳喂养(43.7%)和适当服用铁叶酸(56.8%)的覆盖率较低。邦因素解释了23%的CoC得分。奥里萨邦是一个相对欠发达的邦,排名第一,其他欠发达邦如中央邦和恰蒂斯加尔邦的表现也优于较富裕的邦。但许多传统上较弱的北部和东北部邦仍然落后。
奥里萨邦和其他一些印度欠发达邦表明,即使资源有限,也许通过加强公共卫生系统,也可以实现良好的连续护理覆盖。其他邦应该效仿,帮助印度实现其所有母婴二元组的全面连续护理覆盖,并实现与孕产妇、新生儿和儿童健康相关的可持续发展目标。