Wilson Daniel, Schirrmeister Robin T, Gemein Lukas A W, Ball Tonio
Neuromedical A.I. Lab, Department of Neurosurgery, Medical Center-University of Freiburg, Faculty of Medicine, University of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany.
BrainLinks-BrainTools, IMBIT (Institute for Machine-Brain Interfacing Technology), University of Freiburg, Freiburg im Breisgau, Germany.
Imaging Neurosci (Camb). 2025 Mar 21;3. doi: 10.1162/imag_a_00511. eCollection 2025.
State-of-the-art performance in electroencephalography (EEG) decoding tasks is currently often achieved with either Deep-Learning (DL) or Riemannian-Geometry-based decoders (RBDs). Recently, there is growing interest in Deep Riemannian Networks (DRNs) possibly combining the advantages of both previous classes of methods. However, there are still a range of topics where additional insight is needed to pave the way for a more widespread application of DRNs in EEG. These include architecture design questions such as network size and end-to-end ability. How these factors affect model performance has not been explored. Additionally, it is not clear how the data within these networks are transformed, and whether this would correlate with traditional EEG decoding. Our study aims to lay the groundwork in the area of these topics through the analysis of DRNs for EEG with a wide range of hyperparameters. Networks were tested on five public EEG datasets and compared with state-of-the-art ConvNets. Here, we propose end-to-end EEG SPDNet (EE(G)-SPDNet), and we show that this wide, end-to-end DRN can outperform the ConvNets, and in doing so use physiologically plausible frequency regions. We also show that the end-to-end approach learns more complex filters than traditional bandpass filters targeting the classical alpha, beta, and gamma frequency bands of the EEG, and that performance can benefit from channel-specific filtering approaches. Additionally, architectural analysis revealed areas for further improvement due to the possible under utilisation of Riemannian specific information throughout the network. Our study, thus, shows how to design and train DRNs to infer task-related information from the raw EEG without the need of handcrafted filterbanks and highlights the potential of end-to-end DRNs such as EE(G)-SPDNet for high-performance EEG decoding.
目前,在脑电图(EEG)解码任务中,最先进的性能通常是通过深度学习(DL)或基于黎曼几何的解码器(RBD)实现的。最近,人们对深度黎曼网络(DRN)的兴趣日益浓厚,它可能结合了前两类方法的优点。然而,仍有一系列主题需要进一步深入了解,以便为DRN在EEG中的更广泛应用铺平道路。这些主题包括架构设计问题,如网络规模和端到端能力。这些因素如何影响模型性能尚未得到探索。此外,尚不清楚这些网络中的数据是如何转换的,以及这是否与传统的EEG解码相关。我们的研究旨在通过分析具有广泛超参数的用于EEG的DRN,在这些主题领域奠定基础。在五个公开的EEG数据集上对网络进行了测试,并与最先进的卷积神经网络(ConvNet)进行了比较。在此,我们提出了端到端的EEG SPDNet(EE(G)-SPDNet),并且我们表明这种广泛的端到端DRN可以超越ConvNet,并且在此过程中使用生理上合理的频率区域。我们还表明,端到端方法学习的滤波器比针对EEG经典α、β和γ频段的传统带通滤波器更复杂,并且性能可以受益于特定通道的滤波方法。此外,架构分析揭示了由于整个网络可能未充分利用黎曼特定信息而需要进一步改进的领域。因此,我们的研究展示了如何设计和训练DRN,以便从原始EEG中推断与任务相关的信息,而无需手工制作的滤波器组,并突出了诸如EE(G)-SPDNet这样的端到端DRN在高性能EEG解码方面的潜力。