Hori Arinobu, Ando Emiko, Ozaki Akihiko, Murakami Michio, Tsubokura Masaharu, Oshima Fumiyo
Department of Psychiatry, Hori Mental Clinic, Minamisoma, Fukushima, Japan.
Department of Neuropsychiatry, Fukushima Medical University School of Medicine, Fukushima, Fukushima, Japan.
Case Rep Psychiatry. 2025 Aug 6;2025:9195824. doi: 10.1155/crps/9195824. eCollection 2025.
This case study examined the long-term course and treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) following the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake (GEJE) and nuclear disaster. Specifically, this study investigated the role of early maladaptive schemas (EMSs) and coping modes in symptom persistence, the interplay between physical health issues and PTSD symptoms, and the efficacy of a staged treatment approach. We present a 12-year longitudinal case study of a woman with delayed-onset PTSD. The patient underwent a staged treatment comprising supportive therapy, schema therapy, and prolonged exposure (PE) therapy. Treatment progress and symptom manifestations were qualitatively analyzed, focusing on schema modifications, coping mode changes, and trauma processing. The key findings were: (1) EMSs (e.g., enmeshment and subjugation) contributed to PTSD symptom maintenance and influenced postdisaster interpersonal patterns; (2) maladaptive coping modes played a role in symptom persistence and delayed disease onset; (3) the observed cyclical pattern of symptom exacerbation was particularly evident in the anniversary effect; (4) the staged treatment approach effectively addressed complex PTSD, with schema therapy facilitating subsequent trauma-focused interventions. This study highlights the potential of combining schema therapy and PE to treat complex delayed-onset PTSD following compound disasters. This underscores the importance of addressing the underlying cognitive structures and coping mechanisms alongside trauma-focused interventions. These findings have implications for postdisaster long-term mental healthcare planning and suggest directions for future research to optimize treatment approaches for persistent PTSD.
本案例研究考察了2011年东日本大地震(GEJE)及核灾难后创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的长期病程及治疗情况。具体而言,本研究调查了早期适应不良图式(EMSs)和应对方式在症状持续中的作用、身体健康问题与PTSD症状之间的相互作用,以及分阶段治疗方法的疗效。我们呈现了一位迟发性PTSD女性患者的12年纵向案例研究。该患者接受了包括支持性治疗、图式治疗和延长暴露(PE)治疗的分阶段治疗。对治疗进展和症状表现进行了定性分析,重点关注图式改变、应对方式变化和创伤处理。主要发现如下:(1)EMSs(如纠缠和屈从)导致PTSD症状持续,并影响灾后人际关系模式;(2)适应不良的应对方式在症状持续和疾病延迟发作中起作用;(3)观察到的症状加重的周期性模式在周年效应中尤为明显;(4)分阶段治疗方法有效解决了复杂性PTSD,图式治疗促进了后续以创伤为重点的干预措施。本研究强调了结合图式治疗和PE治疗复合灾难后复杂性迟发性PTSD的潜力。这凸显了在以创伤为重点的干预措施之外解决潜在认知结构和应对机制的重要性。这些发现对灾后长期心理卫生保健规划具有启示意义,并为未来研究优化持续性PTSD的治疗方法指明了方向。