Fatima Fozia, Siddiqui Fuad Ahmad, Ali Sabir, Fatima Safia, Zahoor Asiya, Alvi Alina
Department of Health Professions Education, National University of Medical Sciences, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Educational Development, University of Baltistan, Skardu, Pakistan.
Front Psychiatry. 2025 Jul 30;16:1543308. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2025.1543308. eCollection 2025.
The study explores the relationship between empathy and assertiveness among undergraduate medical students in Punjab, Pakistan. Empathy, critical for patient care, enhances understanding and communication, while assertiveness is vital for advocacy and effective decision-making. Conducted as a cross-sectional analysis with 104 students from two medical colleges, the study used the Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy (JSPE) and the Rathus Assertiveness Schedule (RAS) to evaluate these traits. Results reveal moderate levels of empathy and assertiveness, characterized by the recognition of emotional understanding's importance in patient care, though practical application remains inconsistent. Assertiveness is higher in professional contexts but lower in personal boundary-setting, indicating gaps in interpersonal confidence. The study identifies no significant differences in empathy across gender, academic year, age, or college but finds that female students exhibit significantly higher assertiveness. Regression analysis shows a weak association between empathy and assertiveness, suggesting these traits develop independently and require distinct training. The findings highlight the need for structured educational interventions to bridge these gaps, such as narrative medicine, role-playing, and assertiveness workshops. Addressing cultural and academic challenges, the study underscores the importance of fostering empathetic and assertive behaviors in medical students to enhance both patient care and professional communication. This research contributes to optimizing medical education and preparing students for the complex demands of the healthcare profession.
该研究探讨了巴基斯坦旁遮普省本科医学生同理心与自信之间的关系。同理心对患者护理至关重要,可增强理解与沟通,而自信对于自我主张和有效决策至关重要。该研究对来自两所医学院的104名学生进行了横断面分析,使用杰斐逊医生同理心量表(JSPE)和拉瑟斯自信量表(RAS)来评估这些特质。结果显示,同理心和自信处于中等水平,其特点是认识到情感理解在患者护理中的重要性,尽管实际应用仍不一致。自信在专业环境中较高,但在个人边界设定方面较低,表明人际自信存在差距。该研究发现,不同性别、学年、年龄或学院的学生在同理心方面没有显著差异,但发现女学生的自信水平明显更高。回归分析显示同理心与自信之间的关联较弱,表明这些特质是独立发展的,需要不同的训练。研究结果凸显了开展结构化教育干预以弥合这些差距的必要性,如叙事医学、角色扮演和自信培训工作坊。该研究应对了文化和学术挑战,强调了培养医学生同理心和自信行为对于改善患者护理和专业沟通的重要性。这项研究有助于优化医学教育,使学生为医疗行业的复杂需求做好准备。