Go Matthew C
SNA International, supporting the Department of Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency, Scientific Analysis Directorate, 590 Moffet Street, Building 4077, Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam, Hawaii, 96853, USA.
Int J Legal Med. 2025 Aug 20. doi: 10.1007/s00414-025-03580-5.
The cranium can serve as an important indicator of sex for cases of unidentified human remains. However, the relative magnitude and expression of cranial sexual dimorphism varies across human populations such that population-specific methods are often warranted. Here, population-specific sex estimation equations are developed for both metric and nonmetric traits using contemporary Filipino crania. Cross-validated linear discriminant functions using craniometrics produced total correct classification accuracies between 78.8% and 91.3%, while logistic regression equations using cranial nonmetric traits produced total correct classification accuracies between 63.8 and 89.7%. Exogenous population equations developed in other studies are also applied to the present Filipino sample to evaluate their performance and elucidate insights on variation in human sexual dimorphism. Filipino crania generally classify extremely poorly when using either craniometric or nonmetric equations developed from other populations, with Filipino males tending to classify as female. When considering the performance of Filipinos using equations derived from other Asian groups, conventional assumptions in forensic anthropology of the homogeneity of continental ancestry groupings often do not hold up, such that one Asian population cannot automatically substitute for another Asian population without validation. This paper adds to the growing armamentarium of Filipino-specific methods for sex estimation, which may find utility in various contexts where issues of missing persons arise, including in criminal investigation, disaster victim identification, migration, armed conflict, and war dead repatriation.
对于身份不明的人类遗骸案例,颅骨可作为重要的性别指示指标。然而,颅骨性别二态性的相对大小和表现因人群而异,因此通常需要采用针对特定人群的方法。在此,利用当代菲律宾人的颅骨,针对测量性状和非测量性状分别开发了特定人群的性别估计方程。使用颅骨测量学的交叉验证线性判别函数得出的总正确分类准确率在78.8%至91.3%之间,而使用颅骨非测量性状的逻辑回归方程得出的总正确分类准确率在63.8%至89.7%之间。其他研究中开发的外部人群方程也应用于当前的菲律宾样本,以评估其性能并阐明关于人类性别二态性变异的见解。当使用从其他人群开发的颅骨测量或非测量方程时,菲律宾人的颅骨通常分类效果极差,菲律宾男性往往被误分类为女性。在考虑使用源自其他亚洲群体的方程对菲律宾人进行分类的性能时,法医人类学中关于大陆祖先群体同质性的传统假设往往不成立,因此在未经验证的情况下,一个亚洲人群不能自动替代另一个亚洲人群。本文增加了针对菲律宾人的性别估计方法,这些方法可能在失踪人员问题出现的各种情况下有用,包括刑事调查、灾难受害者身份识别、移民、武装冲突和战争死亡人员遣返。